Should you avoid redundant information after dialogue?How to improve the ending of my short novel (mostly dialogue)?How to make a debate/discussion between characters less dry?Craft group exercises or chapters in critique groups?Capitalisation after punctuation in dialogueUsing exclamation points in fictionCapitalization after interrupted dialogueShould you avoid offensive hyperbole?How to avoid pages of dialogue?When should the dialogue reference be written, before or after the dialogue?Using ”as” after dialogue tags
How to tell readers that I know my story is factually incorrect?
She told me that she HAS / HAD a gun
What's so great about Shalantha's Delicate Disk?
What does "play in traffic" mean?
Where can I find standards for statistical acronyms and whether they should be capitalized or lower case?
I have a domain, static IP and many devices I'd like to access outside my house. How to route them?
Why didn't Balak request Bilam to bless his own people?
What is the origin of "Wonder begets wisdom?"
What's the physical meaning of the statement that "photons don't have positions"?
You have no, but can try for yes
Conditional statement in a function for PS1 are not re-evalutated
A bicolour masyu
Brute-force the switchboard
Why would word of Princess Leia's capture generate sympathy for the Rebellion in the Senate?
How far off did Apollo 11 land?
What is the difference between uniform velocity and constant velocity?
Install suspension forks on non-suspension bike
ISCSI, multiple initiaros for the same lun
Is there an English word to describe when a sound "protrudes"?
What is this light passenger prop airplane which crash landed in East Kalimantan, Borneo in 1983?
Remove side menu(right side) from finder
1025th term of the given sequence.
Can a creature sustain itself by eating its own severed body parts?
Do we have to introduce the character's name before using their names in a dialogue tag?
Should you avoid redundant information after dialogue?
How to improve the ending of my short novel (mostly dialogue)?How to make a debate/discussion between characters less dry?Craft group exercises or chapters in critique groups?Capitalisation after punctuation in dialogueUsing exclamation points in fictionCapitalization after interrupted dialogueShould you avoid offensive hyperbole?How to avoid pages of dialogue?When should the dialogue reference be written, before or after the dialogue?Using ”as” after dialogue tags
.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__bot-mid-leaderboard:empty margin-bottom:0;
Should we avoid repeating redundant information after a dialogue and is there a way around this? Sometimes, you feel prompted to write the description of an action that follows a line, but that also seems to be redundant, and it leads to some pretty bad prose. How would you work around this?
For example:
"Here's the chip in question." he said as he handed the chip to him.
"It's a very old chip, make sure you take care of it."
Sounds redundant, but the fact he's handing it is also important somewhat, or can be important for what may follow. What would you do in this situation?
creative-writing dialogue
edited Jul 14 at 0:13
Cyn
27.1k2 gold badges59 silver badges126 bronze badges
asked Jul 12 at 2:10
blackbirdblackbird
9735 silver badges17 bronze badges
add a comment |
Should we avoid repeating redundant information after a dialogue and is there a way around this? Sometimes, you feel prompted to write the description of an action that follows a line, but that also seems to be redundant, and it leads to some pretty bad prose. How would you work around this?
For example:
"Here's the chip in question." he said as he handed the chip to him.
"It's a very old chip, make sure you take care of it."
Sounds redundant, but the fact he's handing it is also important somewhat, or can be important for what may follow. What would you do in this situation?
creative-writing dialogue
edited Jul 14 at 0:13
Cyn
27.1k2 gold badges59 silver badges126 bronze badges
asked Jul 12 at 2:10
blackbirdblackbird
9735 silver badges17 bronze badges
1
Would you say, "Here's the chip in question. It's a very old chip", or would you say, "Here's the chip in question. It's very old"? That's the answer.
– RonJohn
Jul 13 at 15:57
Any time I attempt trimming down on redundancy in my writing, I just think back to William Gibson's writing in Neuromancer. What concise yet rich language that author has!
– BMF
Jul 13 at 20:14
1
@RonJohn "Here you go," he said as he handed <name> the chip. "It's very old. Make sure you take care of it."
– some_guy632
Jul 14 at 6:04
add a comment |
Should we avoid repeating redundant information after a dialogue and is there a way around this? Sometimes, you feel prompted to write the description of an action that follows a line, but that also seems to be redundant, and it leads to some pretty bad prose. How would you work around this?
For example:
"Here's the chip in question." he said as he handed the chip to him.
"It's a very old chip, make sure you take care of it."
Sounds redundant, but the fact he's handing it is also important somewhat, or can be important for what may follow. What would you do in this situation?
creative-writing dialogue
edited Jul 14 at 0:13
Cyn
27.1k2 gold badges59 silver badges126 bronze badges
asked Jul 12 at 2:10
blackbirdblackbird
9735 silver badges17 bronze badges
Should we avoid repeating redundant information after a dialogue and is there a way around this? Sometimes, you feel prompted to write the description of an action that follows a line, but that also seems to be redundant, and it leads to some pretty bad prose. How would you work around this?
For example:
"Here's the chip in question." he said as he handed the chip to him.
"It's a very old chip, make sure you take care of it."
Sounds redundant, but the fact he's handing it is also important somewhat, or can be important for what may follow. What would you do in this situation?
creative-writing dialogue
creative-writing dialogue
edited Jul 14 at 0:13
Cyn
27.1k2 gold badges59 silver badges126 bronze badges
asked Jul 12 at 2:10
blackbirdblackbird
9735 silver badges17 bronze badges
edited Jul 14 at 0:13
Cyn
27.1k2 gold badges59 silver badges126 bronze badges
asked Jul 12 at 2:10
blackbirdblackbird
9735 silver badges17 bronze badges
edited Jul 14 at 0:13
Cyn
27.1k2 gold badges59 silver badges126 bronze badges
edited Jul 14 at 0:13
Cyn
27.1k2 gold badges59 silver badges126 bronze badges
edited Jul 14 at 0:13
Cyn
27.1k2 gold badges59 silver badges126 bronze badges
27.1k2 gold badges59 silver badges126 bronze badges
asked Jul 12 at 2:10
blackbirdblackbird
9735 silver badges17 bronze badges
asked Jul 12 at 2:10
blackbirdblackbird
9735 silver badges17 bronze badges
asked Jul 12 at 2:10
blackbirdblackbird
9735 silver badges17 bronze badges
9735 silver badges17 bronze badges
1
Would you say, "Here's the chip in question. It's a very old chip", or would you say, "Here's the chip in question. It's very old"? That's the answer.
– RonJohn
Jul 13 at 15:57
Any time I attempt trimming down on redundancy in my writing, I just think back to William Gibson's writing in Neuromancer. What concise yet rich language that author has!
– BMF
Jul 13 at 20:14
1
@RonJohn "Here you go," he said as he handed <name> the chip. "It's very old. Make sure you take care of it."
– some_guy632
Jul 14 at 6:04
add a comment |
1
Would you say, "Here's the chip in question. It's a very old chip", or would you say, "Here's the chip in question. It's very old"? That's the answer.
– RonJohn
Jul 13 at 15:57
Any time I attempt trimming down on redundancy in my writing, I just think back to William Gibson's writing in Neuromancer. What concise yet rich language that author has!
– BMF
Jul 13 at 20:14
1
@RonJohn "Here you go," he said as he handed <name> the chip. "It's very old. Make sure you take care of it."
– some_guy632
Jul 14 at 6:04
1
1
Would you say, "Here's the chip in question. It's a very old chip", or would you say, "Here's the chip in question. It's very old"? That's the answer.
– RonJohn
Jul 13 at 15:57
Would you say, "Here's the chip in question. It's a very old chip", or would you say, "Here's the chip in question. It's very old"? That's the answer.
– RonJohn
Jul 13 at 15:57
Any time I attempt trimming down on redundancy in my writing, I just think back to William Gibson's writing in Neuromancer. What concise yet rich language that author has!
– BMF
Jul 13 at 20:14
Any time I attempt trimming down on redundancy in my writing, I just think back to William Gibson's writing in Neuromancer. What concise yet rich language that author has!
– BMF
Jul 13 at 20:14
1
1
@RonJohn "Here you go," he said as he handed <name> the chip. "It's very old. Make sure you take care of it."
– some_guy632
Jul 14 at 6:04
@RonJohn "Here you go," he said as he handed <name> the chip. "It's very old. Make sure you take care of it."
– some_guy632
Jul 14 at 6:04
add a comment |
6 Answers
6
active
oldest
votes
Should you avoid redundancy?
Yes.
How do you get around this?
Cut the redundant part and show only the new information.
Infinitezero has already given a good example on that.
"Here's the chip in question." He pulled it out from his pocket with slow, deliberate gestures. He gave out the impression of an elephant trying to move bohemian crystal around. "It's a very old one, make sure you take care of it".
As you can see, I've omitted "he said", since here it can be implied neatly.
If there's nothing new to tell, you don't have to make it up:
"Here's the chip in question." He said. "It's a very old one, make sure you take care of it".
Here the pause is still effective, since it cuts the dialogue lines. The lack of further information leaves the reader imagining the chip being passed.
answered Jul 12 at 8:46
LiquidLiquid
12.3k2 gold badges38 silver badges100 bronze badges
4
You could also come from the other person's perspective: "... make sure you take care of it." -> Jim took the package and carefully stowed it in his Acme Supperr Secure LokBox.
– Cullub
Jul 12 at 20:04
1
I think it should be"Here's the chip in question." He pulled it out from his pocket with slow, deliberate gestures.
– Acccumulation
Jul 15 at 18:54
@Acccumulation Noted.
– Liquid
Jul 15 at 22:34
add a comment |
Why don't you paraphrase the action? Say what he is literally doing. How does he give the chip? Is it in an envelope? Does he extend his arm? Is he tossing it? ....
"Here's the chip in question" he said as he passed him the sealed envelope, making sure [Jack] had a firm grip on it before he let go. "It's a very old one, make sure you take care of it.
answered Jul 12 at 6:04
infinitezeroinfinitezero
3711 silver badge4 bronze badges
5
Key point to note here seems to be to highlight the difference between "repeating redundant information" to the reader, and instead expanding on the information presented to the reader, and reinforcing the information. - "Can this be reworded to add more detail or important information about what is going on?" [Just keep in mind that at times, less is still more.]
– TheLuckless
Jul 12 at 17:42
add a comment |
Just get rid of the redundancies, and it will sound fine.
Original: "Here's the chip in question." he said as he handed to chip to him. "It's a very old chip, make sure you take care of it."
Revised: "Here's the chip in question," he said, as he handed it to him, "It's very old, make sure you take care of it."
You don't have to repeat "chip" every time. An alternative is to name the object second:
Revised: "This is the one," he said, handing him an anti-stat bag holding a chip. "It's very old, make sure you take care of it."
answered Jul 12 at 19:44
AmadeusAmadeus
69k7 gold badges90 silver badges225 bronze badges
add a comment |
Redundancy is good, but in writing it is better to re-phrase than to repeat. Repeating is ok in dialog, as long as that is just how that character speaks, but outside dialog you should check if you are repeating any words, and try to avoid that. If you need to, walk away for a day and re-read it to see if anything sounds weird/off.
"Here's the chip in question." he said as he handed it to me. "It's a very old chip, make sure you take care of it."
(He and Him imply the same person in this context, so will confuse some readers on first read through)
answered Jul 12 at 17:16
TezraTezra
1613 bronze badges
add a comment |
In the palm of his hand was an old, rugged chip. As he extended his arm towards me he said: "It's very old. Take good care of it."
Don't know if this helps, but this is what I would make of it. :-) Redundancy in writing is for me as a reader really annoying.
answered Jul 14 at 15:50
El ViraEl Vira
111 bronze badge
add a comment |
Redundancy is neither good nor bad. It either works for you or doesn't. In your brief lines, you have a lot of redundancy that, not knowing the context, can probably be removed without sacrificing understandability.
"Here's the chip. It's very old so make sure you take care of it."
"In question" isn't needed. The handing over of the chip isn't needed; it's implied with "here's the chip" and in the next sentence the other character will pocket it so it's clear that he has it.
Seems to me that there's no need to linger on that sentence any longer than that. Just pass the coin and get on with the story.
answered Jul 15 at 17:16
Ken MohnkernKen Mohnkern
3,4437 silver badges21 bronze badges
add a comment |
Your Answer
StackExchange.ready(function()
var channelOptions =
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "166"
;
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
createEditor();
);
else
createEditor();
);
function createEditor()
StackExchange.prepareEditor(
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader:
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
,
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
);
);
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fwriting.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f46558%2fshould-you-avoid-redundant-information-after-dialogue%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
6 Answers
6
active
oldest
votes
6 Answers
6
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
Should you avoid redundancy?
Yes.
How do you get around this?
Cut the redundant part and show only the new information.
Infinitezero has already given a good example on that.
"Here's the chip in question." He pulled it out from his pocket with slow, deliberate gestures. He gave out the impression of an elephant trying to move bohemian crystal around. "It's a very old one, make sure you take care of it".
As you can see, I've omitted "he said", since here it can be implied neatly.
If there's nothing new to tell, you don't have to make it up:
"Here's the chip in question." He said. "It's a very old one, make sure you take care of it".
Here the pause is still effective, since it cuts the dialogue lines. The lack of further information leaves the reader imagining the chip being passed.
answered Jul 12 at 8:46
LiquidLiquid
12.3k2 gold badges38 silver badges100 bronze badges
4
You could also come from the other person's perspective: "... make sure you take care of it." -> Jim took the package and carefully stowed it in his Acme Supperr Secure LokBox.
– Cullub
Jul 12 at 20:04
1
I think it should be"Here's the chip in question." He pulled it out from his pocket with slow, deliberate gestures.
– Acccumulation
Jul 15 at 18:54
@Acccumulation Noted.
– Liquid
Jul 15 at 22:34
add a comment |
Should you avoid redundancy?
Yes.
How do you get around this?
Cut the redundant part and show only the new information.
Infinitezero has already given a good example on that.
"Here's the chip in question." He pulled it out from his pocket with slow, deliberate gestures. He gave out the impression of an elephant trying to move bohemian crystal around. "It's a very old one, make sure you take care of it".
As you can see, I've omitted "he said", since here it can be implied neatly.
If there's nothing new to tell, you don't have to make it up:
"Here's the chip in question." He said. "It's a very old one, make sure you take care of it".
Here the pause is still effective, since it cuts the dialogue lines. The lack of further information leaves the reader imagining the chip being passed.
answered Jul 12 at 8:46
LiquidLiquid
12.3k2 gold badges38 silver badges100 bronze badges
4
You could also come from the other person's perspective: "... make sure you take care of it." -> Jim took the package and carefully stowed it in his Acme Supperr Secure LokBox.
– Cullub
Jul 12 at 20:04
1
I think it should be"Here's the chip in question." He pulled it out from his pocket with slow, deliberate gestures.
– Acccumulation
Jul 15 at 18:54
@Acccumulation Noted.
– Liquid
Jul 15 at 22:34
add a comment |
Should you avoid redundancy?
Yes.
How do you get around this?
Cut the redundant part and show only the new information.
Infinitezero has already given a good example on that.
"Here's the chip in question." He pulled it out from his pocket with slow, deliberate gestures. He gave out the impression of an elephant trying to move bohemian crystal around. "It's a very old one, make sure you take care of it".
As you can see, I've omitted "he said", since here it can be implied neatly.
If there's nothing new to tell, you don't have to make it up:
"Here's the chip in question." He said. "It's a very old one, make sure you take care of it".
Here the pause is still effective, since it cuts the dialogue lines. The lack of further information leaves the reader imagining the chip being passed.
answered Jul 12 at 8:46
LiquidLiquid
12.3k2 gold badges38 silver badges100 bronze badges
Should you avoid redundancy?
Yes.
How do you get around this?
Cut the redundant part and show only the new information.
Infinitezero has already given a good example on that.
"Here's the chip in question." He pulled it out from his pocket with slow, deliberate gestures. He gave out the impression of an elephant trying to move bohemian crystal around. "It's a very old one, make sure you take care of it".
As you can see, I've omitted "he said", since here it can be implied neatly.
If there's nothing new to tell, you don't have to make it up:
"Here's the chip in question." He said. "It's a very old one, make sure you take care of it".
Here the pause is still effective, since it cuts the dialogue lines. The lack of further information leaves the reader imagining the chip being passed.
answered Jul 12 at 8:46
LiquidLiquid
12.3k2 gold badges38 silver badges100 bronze badges
edited Jul 15 at 22:35
answered Jul 12 at 8:46
LiquidLiquid
12.3k2 gold badges38 silver badges100 bronze badges
answered Jul 12 at 8:46
LiquidLiquid
12.3k2 gold badges38 silver badges100 bronze badges
answered Jul 12 at 8:46
LiquidLiquid
12.3k2 gold badges38 silver badges100 bronze badges
12.3k2 gold badges38 silver badges100 bronze badges
4
You could also come from the other person's perspective: "... make sure you take care of it." -> Jim took the package and carefully stowed it in his Acme Supperr Secure LokBox.
– Cullub
Jul 12 at 20:04
1
I think it should be"Here's the chip in question." He pulled it out from his pocket with slow, deliberate gestures.
– Acccumulation
Jul 15 at 18:54
@Acccumulation Noted.
– Liquid
Jul 15 at 22:34
add a comment |
4
You could also come from the other person's perspective: "... make sure you take care of it." -> Jim took the package and carefully stowed it in his Acme Supperr Secure LokBox.
– Cullub
Jul 12 at 20:04
1
I think it should be"Here's the chip in question." He pulled it out from his pocket with slow, deliberate gestures.
– Acccumulation
Jul 15 at 18:54
@Acccumulation Noted.
– Liquid
Jul 15 at 22:34
4
4
You could also come from the other person's perspective: "... make sure you take care of it." -> Jim took the package and carefully stowed it in his Acme Supperr Secure LokBox.
– Cullub
Jul 12 at 20:04
You could also come from the other person's perspective: "... make sure you take care of it." -> Jim took the package and carefully stowed it in his Acme Supperr Secure LokBox.
– Cullub
Jul 12 at 20:04
1
1
I think it should be
"Here's the chip in question." He pulled it out from his pocket with slow, deliberate gestures.– Acccumulation
Jul 15 at 18:54
I think it should be
"Here's the chip in question." He pulled it out from his pocket with slow, deliberate gestures.– Acccumulation
Jul 15 at 18:54
@Acccumulation Noted.
– Liquid
Jul 15 at 22:34
@Acccumulation Noted.
– Liquid
Jul 15 at 22:34
add a comment |
Why don't you paraphrase the action? Say what he is literally doing. How does he give the chip? Is it in an envelope? Does he extend his arm? Is he tossing it? ....
"Here's the chip in question" he said as he passed him the sealed envelope, making sure [Jack] had a firm grip on it before he let go. "It's a very old one, make sure you take care of it.
answered Jul 12 at 6:04
infinitezeroinfinitezero
3711 silver badge4 bronze badges
5
Key point to note here seems to be to highlight the difference between "repeating redundant information" to the reader, and instead expanding on the information presented to the reader, and reinforcing the information. - "Can this be reworded to add more detail or important information about what is going on?" [Just keep in mind that at times, less is still more.]
– TheLuckless
Jul 12 at 17:42
add a comment |
Why don't you paraphrase the action? Say what he is literally doing. How does he give the chip? Is it in an envelope? Does he extend his arm? Is he tossing it? ....
"Here's the chip in question" he said as he passed him the sealed envelope, making sure [Jack] had a firm grip on it before he let go. "It's a very old one, make sure you take care of it.
answered Jul 12 at 6:04
infinitezeroinfinitezero
3711 silver badge4 bronze badges
5
Key point to note here seems to be to highlight the difference between "repeating redundant information" to the reader, and instead expanding on the information presented to the reader, and reinforcing the information. - "Can this be reworded to add more detail or important information about what is going on?" [Just keep in mind that at times, less is still more.]
– TheLuckless
Jul 12 at 17:42
add a comment |
Why don't you paraphrase the action? Say what he is literally doing. How does he give the chip? Is it in an envelope? Does he extend his arm? Is he tossing it? ....
"Here's the chip in question" he said as he passed him the sealed envelope, making sure [Jack] had a firm grip on it before he let go. "It's a very old one, make sure you take care of it.
answered Jul 12 at 6:04
infinitezeroinfinitezero
3711 silver badge4 bronze badges
Why don't you paraphrase the action? Say what he is literally doing. How does he give the chip? Is it in an envelope? Does he extend his arm? Is he tossing it? ....
"Here's the chip in question" he said as he passed him the sealed envelope, making sure [Jack] had a firm grip on it before he let go. "It's a very old one, make sure you take care of it.
answered Jul 12 at 6:04
infinitezeroinfinitezero
3711 silver badge4 bronze badges
answered Jul 12 at 6:04
infinitezeroinfinitezero
3711 silver badge4 bronze badges
answered Jul 12 at 6:04
infinitezeroinfinitezero
3711 silver badge4 bronze badges
answered Jul 12 at 6:04
infinitezeroinfinitezero
3711 silver badge4 bronze badges
3711 silver badge4 bronze badges
5
Key point to note here seems to be to highlight the difference between "repeating redundant information" to the reader, and instead expanding on the information presented to the reader, and reinforcing the information. - "Can this be reworded to add more detail or important information about what is going on?" [Just keep in mind that at times, less is still more.]
– TheLuckless
Jul 12 at 17:42
add a comment |
5
Key point to note here seems to be to highlight the difference between "repeating redundant information" to the reader, and instead expanding on the information presented to the reader, and reinforcing the information. - "Can this be reworded to add more detail or important information about what is going on?" [Just keep in mind that at times, less is still more.]
– TheLuckless
Jul 12 at 17:42
5
5
Key point to note here seems to be to highlight the difference between "repeating redundant information" to the reader, and instead expanding on the information presented to the reader, and reinforcing the information. - "Can this be reworded to add more detail or important information about what is going on?" [Just keep in mind that at times, less is still more.]
– TheLuckless
Jul 12 at 17:42
Key point to note here seems to be to highlight the difference between "repeating redundant information" to the reader, and instead expanding on the information presented to the reader, and reinforcing the information. - "Can this be reworded to add more detail or important information about what is going on?" [Just keep in mind that at times, less is still more.]
– TheLuckless
Jul 12 at 17:42
add a comment |
Just get rid of the redundancies, and it will sound fine.
Original: "Here's the chip in question." he said as he handed to chip to him. "It's a very old chip, make sure you take care of it."
Revised: "Here's the chip in question," he said, as he handed it to him, "It's very old, make sure you take care of it."
You don't have to repeat "chip" every time. An alternative is to name the object second:
Revised: "This is the one," he said, handing him an anti-stat bag holding a chip. "It's very old, make sure you take care of it."
answered Jul 12 at 19:44
AmadeusAmadeus
69k7 gold badges90 silver badges225 bronze badges
add a comment |
Just get rid of the redundancies, and it will sound fine.
Original: "Here's the chip in question." he said as he handed to chip to him. "It's a very old chip, make sure you take care of it."
Revised: "Here's the chip in question," he said, as he handed it to him, "It's very old, make sure you take care of it."
You don't have to repeat "chip" every time. An alternative is to name the object second:
Revised: "This is the one," he said, handing him an anti-stat bag holding a chip. "It's very old, make sure you take care of it."
answered Jul 12 at 19:44
AmadeusAmadeus
69k7 gold badges90 silver badges225 bronze badges
add a comment |
Just get rid of the redundancies, and it will sound fine.
Original: "Here's the chip in question." he said as he handed to chip to him. "It's a very old chip, make sure you take care of it."
Revised: "Here's the chip in question," he said, as he handed it to him, "It's very old, make sure you take care of it."
You don't have to repeat "chip" every time. An alternative is to name the object second:
Revised: "This is the one," he said, handing him an anti-stat bag holding a chip. "It's very old, make sure you take care of it."
answered Jul 12 at 19:44
AmadeusAmadeus
69k7 gold badges90 silver badges225 bronze badges
Just get rid of the redundancies, and it will sound fine.
Original: "Here's the chip in question." he said as he handed to chip to him. "It's a very old chip, make sure you take care of it."
Revised: "Here's the chip in question," he said, as he handed it to him, "It's very old, make sure you take care of it."
You don't have to repeat "chip" every time. An alternative is to name the object second:
Revised: "This is the one," he said, handing him an anti-stat bag holding a chip. "It's very old, make sure you take care of it."
answered Jul 12 at 19:44
AmadeusAmadeus
69k7 gold badges90 silver badges225 bronze badges
answered Jul 12 at 19:44
AmadeusAmadeus
69k7 gold badges90 silver badges225 bronze badges
answered Jul 12 at 19:44
AmadeusAmadeus
69k7 gold badges90 silver badges225 bronze badges
answered Jul 12 at 19:44
AmadeusAmadeus
69k7 gold badges90 silver badges225 bronze badges
69k7 gold badges90 silver badges225 bronze badges
add a comment |
add a comment |
Redundancy is good, but in writing it is better to re-phrase than to repeat. Repeating is ok in dialog, as long as that is just how that character speaks, but outside dialog you should check if you are repeating any words, and try to avoid that. If you need to, walk away for a day and re-read it to see if anything sounds weird/off.
"Here's the chip in question." he said as he handed it to me. "It's a very old chip, make sure you take care of it."
(He and Him imply the same person in this context, so will confuse some readers on first read through)
answered Jul 12 at 17:16
TezraTezra
1613 bronze badges
add a comment |
Redundancy is good, but in writing it is better to re-phrase than to repeat. Repeating is ok in dialog, as long as that is just how that character speaks, but outside dialog you should check if you are repeating any words, and try to avoid that. If you need to, walk away for a day and re-read it to see if anything sounds weird/off.
"Here's the chip in question." he said as he handed it to me. "It's a very old chip, make sure you take care of it."
(He and Him imply the same person in this context, so will confuse some readers on first read through)
answered Jul 12 at 17:16
TezraTezra
1613 bronze badges
add a comment |
Redundancy is good, but in writing it is better to re-phrase than to repeat. Repeating is ok in dialog, as long as that is just how that character speaks, but outside dialog you should check if you are repeating any words, and try to avoid that. If you need to, walk away for a day and re-read it to see if anything sounds weird/off.
"Here's the chip in question." he said as he handed it to me. "It's a very old chip, make sure you take care of it."
(He and Him imply the same person in this context, so will confuse some readers on first read through)
answered Jul 12 at 17:16
TezraTezra
1613 bronze badges
Redundancy is good, but in writing it is better to re-phrase than to repeat. Repeating is ok in dialog, as long as that is just how that character speaks, but outside dialog you should check if you are repeating any words, and try to avoid that. If you need to, walk away for a day and re-read it to see if anything sounds weird/off.
"Here's the chip in question." he said as he handed it to me. "It's a very old chip, make sure you take care of it."
(He and Him imply the same person in this context, so will confuse some readers on first read through)
answered Jul 12 at 17:16
TezraTezra
1613 bronze badges
answered Jul 12 at 17:16
TezraTezra
1613 bronze badges
answered Jul 12 at 17:16
TezraTezra
1613 bronze badges
answered Jul 12 at 17:16
TezraTezra
1613 bronze badges
1613 bronze badges
add a comment |
add a comment |
In the palm of his hand was an old, rugged chip. As he extended his arm towards me he said: "It's very old. Take good care of it."
Don't know if this helps, but this is what I would make of it. :-) Redundancy in writing is for me as a reader really annoying.
answered Jul 14 at 15:50
El ViraEl Vira
111 bronze badge
add a comment |
In the palm of his hand was an old, rugged chip. As he extended his arm towards me he said: "It's very old. Take good care of it."
Don't know if this helps, but this is what I would make of it. :-) Redundancy in writing is for me as a reader really annoying.
answered Jul 14 at 15:50
El ViraEl Vira
111 bronze badge
add a comment |
In the palm of his hand was an old, rugged chip. As he extended his arm towards me he said: "It's very old. Take good care of it."
Don't know if this helps, but this is what I would make of it. :-) Redundancy in writing is for me as a reader really annoying.
answered Jul 14 at 15:50
El ViraEl Vira
111 bronze badge
In the palm of his hand was an old, rugged chip. As he extended his arm towards me he said: "It's very old. Take good care of it."
Don't know if this helps, but this is what I would make of it. :-) Redundancy in writing is for me as a reader really annoying.
answered Jul 14 at 15:50
El ViraEl Vira
111 bronze badge
answered Jul 14 at 15:50
El ViraEl Vira
111 bronze badge
answered Jul 14 at 15:50
El ViraEl Vira
111 bronze badge
answered Jul 14 at 15:50
El ViraEl Vira
111 bronze badge
111 bronze badge
add a comment |
add a comment |
Redundancy is neither good nor bad. It either works for you or doesn't. In your brief lines, you have a lot of redundancy that, not knowing the context, can probably be removed without sacrificing understandability.
"Here's the chip. It's very old so make sure you take care of it."
"In question" isn't needed. The handing over of the chip isn't needed; it's implied with "here's the chip" and in the next sentence the other character will pocket it so it's clear that he has it.
Seems to me that there's no need to linger on that sentence any longer than that. Just pass the coin and get on with the story.
answered Jul 15 at 17:16
Ken MohnkernKen Mohnkern
3,4437 silver badges21 bronze badges
add a comment |
Redundancy is neither good nor bad. It either works for you or doesn't. In your brief lines, you have a lot of redundancy that, not knowing the context, can probably be removed without sacrificing understandability.
"Here's the chip. It's very old so make sure you take care of it."
"In question" isn't needed. The handing over of the chip isn't needed; it's implied with "here's the chip" and in the next sentence the other character will pocket it so it's clear that he has it.
Seems to me that there's no need to linger on that sentence any longer than that. Just pass the coin and get on with the story.
answered Jul 15 at 17:16
Ken MohnkernKen Mohnkern
3,4437 silver badges21 bronze badges
add a comment |
Redundancy is neither good nor bad. It either works for you or doesn't. In your brief lines, you have a lot of redundancy that, not knowing the context, can probably be removed without sacrificing understandability.
"Here's the chip. It's very old so make sure you take care of it."
"In question" isn't needed. The handing over of the chip isn't needed; it's implied with "here's the chip" and in the next sentence the other character will pocket it so it's clear that he has it.
Seems to me that there's no need to linger on that sentence any longer than that. Just pass the coin and get on with the story.
answered Jul 15 at 17:16
Ken MohnkernKen Mohnkern
3,4437 silver badges21 bronze badges
Redundancy is neither good nor bad. It either works for you or doesn't. In your brief lines, you have a lot of redundancy that, not knowing the context, can probably be removed without sacrificing understandability.
"Here's the chip. It's very old so make sure you take care of it."
"In question" isn't needed. The handing over of the chip isn't needed; it's implied with "here's the chip" and in the next sentence the other character will pocket it so it's clear that he has it.
Seems to me that there's no need to linger on that sentence any longer than that. Just pass the coin and get on with the story.
answered Jul 15 at 17:16
Ken MohnkernKen Mohnkern
3,4437 silver badges21 bronze badges
answered Jul 15 at 17:16
Ken MohnkernKen Mohnkern
3,4437 silver badges21 bronze badges
answered Jul 15 at 17:16
Ken MohnkernKen Mohnkern
3,4437 silver badges21 bronze badges
answered Jul 15 at 17:16
Ken MohnkernKen Mohnkern
3,4437 silver badges21 bronze badges
3,4437 silver badges21 bronze badges
add a comment |
add a comment |
Thanks for contributing an answer to Writing Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fwriting.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f46558%2fshould-you-avoid-redundant-information-after-dialogue%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
1
Would you say, "Here's the chip in question. It's a very old chip", or would you say, "Here's the chip in question. It's very old"? That's the answer.
– RonJohn
Jul 13 at 15:57
Any time I attempt trimming down on redundancy in my writing, I just think back to William Gibson's writing in Neuromancer. What concise yet rich language that author has!
– BMF
Jul 13 at 20:14
1
@RonJohn "Here you go," he said as he handed <name> the chip. "It's very old. Make sure you take care of it."
– some_guy632
Jul 14 at 6:04