Was Willow's first magic display (blazing arrow through arm) actual magic, and if not, what's the trick?
Explanation for a joke about a three-legged dog that walks into a bar
What is the life span of a Flerken?
Is it legal for private citizens to "impound" e-scooters?
How can I tell if there was a power cut while I was out?
Other than a swing wing, what types of variable geometry have flown?
Spoken encryption
Monty Hall Problem with a Fallible Monty
Inadvertently nuked my disk permission structure - why?
Why keep the bed heated after initial layer(s) with PLA (or PETG)?
How do campaign rallies gain candidates votes?
Why is chess failing to attract big name sponsors?
Why are so many countries still in the Commonwealth?
Why did NASA use U.S customary units?
Problem loading expl3 in plain TeX
How much damage does a magic stone cause when hurled from a sling?
Sextortion with actual password not found in leaks
Invert Some Switches on a Switchboard
Would it be a good idea to memorize relative interval positions on guitar?
What do I do when a student working in my lab "ghosts" me?
Where to place an artificial gland in the human body?
What do teaching faculty do during semester breaks?
The seven story archetypes. Are they truly all of them?
Spacing setting of math mode
Is an easily guessed plot twist a good plot twist?
Was Willow's first magic display (blazing arrow through arm) actual magic, and if not, what's the trick?
.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__bot-mid-leaderboard:empty margin-bottom:0;
At the beginning of Willow, before the wizard chooses his apprentice for the year, Willow participates in a Nelwyn fair where he demonstrates two magic tricks:
- pushing a blazing arrow through a cylinder he wears on his arm (so supposedly, the burning arrow goes through his arm as well) while staying unscathed;
- making a piglet disappear.
The piglet's disappearance is quickly shown to be some sleight-of-hand trick (the piglet was under the stage), which implies the arrow thing was a setup as well.
However, throughout the movie, it seems Willow already has a bit of experience with magic. Sure, he's not really good at it, (transforming Fin Raziel into a crow instead of her human shape, etc.) but the impression I had, through him uttering the words and all, was that Willow had actually practiced some magic already.
Thus, I'm curious whether the fire arrow trick may have been actual magic? It could still be a trick, but in this case I'm wondering what the trick is. The cylinder doesn't look wide enough for Willow to push his arm to the side and have the arrow going besides it, and anyway he would have been burned.
Googling terms like willow nelwyn magic trick explained
or magic trick fire arrow through arm
don't seem to bring up anything relevant, except a "stage magic" wikia page which doesn't say much more than "illusions."
Is there an answer as to how Willow seemingly managed to push a blazing arrow through his arm? I've only seen the movie, not read any novels; perhaps there is an answer there.
willow
add a comment |
At the beginning of Willow, before the wizard chooses his apprentice for the year, Willow participates in a Nelwyn fair where he demonstrates two magic tricks:
- pushing a blazing arrow through a cylinder he wears on his arm (so supposedly, the burning arrow goes through his arm as well) while staying unscathed;
- making a piglet disappear.
The piglet's disappearance is quickly shown to be some sleight-of-hand trick (the piglet was under the stage), which implies the arrow thing was a setup as well.
However, throughout the movie, it seems Willow already has a bit of experience with magic. Sure, he's not really good at it, (transforming Fin Raziel into a crow instead of her human shape, etc.) but the impression I had, through him uttering the words and all, was that Willow had actually practiced some magic already.
Thus, I'm curious whether the fire arrow trick may have been actual magic? It could still be a trick, but in this case I'm wondering what the trick is. The cylinder doesn't look wide enough for Willow to push his arm to the side and have the arrow going besides it, and anyway he would have been burned.
Googling terms like willow nelwyn magic trick explained
or magic trick fire arrow through arm
don't seem to bring up anything relevant, except a "stage magic" wikia page which doesn't say much more than "illusions."
Is there an answer as to how Willow seemingly managed to push a blazing arrow through his arm? I've only seen the movie, not read any novels; perhaps there is an answer there.
willow
1
Given how large the cylinder is (it actually looks like a hollow log to me) compared to his arm, I'm sure it's just a matter of the arrow passing beside his arm. To keep from being burned, he could have put a cloth tube in there (that the arrow passes through) to insulate his skin. Or he could just have done it quickly; those flames are not that hot otherwise a "fire-eater" would get burned by incidental contact.
– DavidW
Jul 15 at 14:42
1
It's an illusion.
– Acccumulation
Jul 15 at 17:14
add a comment |
At the beginning of Willow, before the wizard chooses his apprentice for the year, Willow participates in a Nelwyn fair where he demonstrates two magic tricks:
- pushing a blazing arrow through a cylinder he wears on his arm (so supposedly, the burning arrow goes through his arm as well) while staying unscathed;
- making a piglet disappear.
The piglet's disappearance is quickly shown to be some sleight-of-hand trick (the piglet was under the stage), which implies the arrow thing was a setup as well.
However, throughout the movie, it seems Willow already has a bit of experience with magic. Sure, he's not really good at it, (transforming Fin Raziel into a crow instead of her human shape, etc.) but the impression I had, through him uttering the words and all, was that Willow had actually practiced some magic already.
Thus, I'm curious whether the fire arrow trick may have been actual magic? It could still be a trick, but in this case I'm wondering what the trick is. The cylinder doesn't look wide enough for Willow to push his arm to the side and have the arrow going besides it, and anyway he would have been burned.
Googling terms like willow nelwyn magic trick explained
or magic trick fire arrow through arm
don't seem to bring up anything relevant, except a "stage magic" wikia page which doesn't say much more than "illusions."
Is there an answer as to how Willow seemingly managed to push a blazing arrow through his arm? I've only seen the movie, not read any novels; perhaps there is an answer there.
willow
At the beginning of Willow, before the wizard chooses his apprentice for the year, Willow participates in a Nelwyn fair where he demonstrates two magic tricks:
- pushing a blazing arrow through a cylinder he wears on his arm (so supposedly, the burning arrow goes through his arm as well) while staying unscathed;
- making a piglet disappear.
The piglet's disappearance is quickly shown to be some sleight-of-hand trick (the piglet was under the stage), which implies the arrow thing was a setup as well.
However, throughout the movie, it seems Willow already has a bit of experience with magic. Sure, he's not really good at it, (transforming Fin Raziel into a crow instead of her human shape, etc.) but the impression I had, through him uttering the words and all, was that Willow had actually practiced some magic already.
Thus, I'm curious whether the fire arrow trick may have been actual magic? It could still be a trick, but in this case I'm wondering what the trick is. The cylinder doesn't look wide enough for Willow to push his arm to the side and have the arrow going besides it, and anyway he would have been burned.
Googling terms like willow nelwyn magic trick explained
or magic trick fire arrow through arm
don't seem to bring up anything relevant, except a "stage magic" wikia page which doesn't say much more than "illusions."
Is there an answer as to how Willow seemingly managed to push a blazing arrow through his arm? I've only seen the movie, not read any novels; perhaps there is an answer there.
willow
willow
edited Jul 15 at 16:11
Valorum
434k122 gold badges3195 silver badges3368 bronze badges
434k122 gold badges3195 silver badges3368 bronze badges
asked Jul 15 at 14:30
JenayahJenayah
28.9k9 gold badges129 silver badges175 bronze badges
28.9k9 gold badges129 silver badges175 bronze badges
1
Given how large the cylinder is (it actually looks like a hollow log to me) compared to his arm, I'm sure it's just a matter of the arrow passing beside his arm. To keep from being burned, he could have put a cloth tube in there (that the arrow passes through) to insulate his skin. Or he could just have done it quickly; those flames are not that hot otherwise a "fire-eater" would get burned by incidental contact.
– DavidW
Jul 15 at 14:42
1
It's an illusion.
– Acccumulation
Jul 15 at 17:14
add a comment |
1
Given how large the cylinder is (it actually looks like a hollow log to me) compared to his arm, I'm sure it's just a matter of the arrow passing beside his arm. To keep from being burned, he could have put a cloth tube in there (that the arrow passes through) to insulate his skin. Or he could just have done it quickly; those flames are not that hot otherwise a "fire-eater" would get burned by incidental contact.
– DavidW
Jul 15 at 14:42
1
It's an illusion.
– Acccumulation
Jul 15 at 17:14
1
1
Given how large the cylinder is (it actually looks like a hollow log to me) compared to his arm, I'm sure it's just a matter of the arrow passing beside his arm. To keep from being burned, he could have put a cloth tube in there (that the arrow passes through) to insulate his skin. Or he could just have done it quickly; those flames are not that hot otherwise a "fire-eater" would get burned by incidental contact.
– DavidW
Jul 15 at 14:42
Given how large the cylinder is (it actually looks like a hollow log to me) compared to his arm, I'm sure it's just a matter of the arrow passing beside his arm. To keep from being burned, he could have put a cloth tube in there (that the arrow passes through) to insulate his skin. Or he could just have done it quickly; those flames are not that hot otherwise a "fire-eater" would get burned by incidental contact.
– DavidW
Jul 15 at 14:42
1
1
It's an illusion.
– Acccumulation
Jul 15 at 17:14
It's an illusion.
– Acccumulation
Jul 15 at 17:14
add a comment |
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
It appears to be based directly on this trick. Thus I assume it is meant to be sleight of hand like the piglet trick.
youtu.be/FyU26WN9kuY A do it yourself version of the trick that explains how it's done, at 4:10. Not sure if the manufactured ones work the same way.
– Kai
Jul 15 at 16:13
5
For the reference, "sleight" of hand is how you perform illusions. "Slight" of hand just means you've got really small hands.
– Valorum
Jul 15 at 16:13
1
@Valorum Or someone is disparaging your hands.
– Acccumulation
Jul 15 at 17:13
1
I prefer "legerdemain" or "prestidigitation," personally. "Skulduggery" is a bit underhanded, though.
– Draco18s
Jul 16 at 14:52
add a comment |
The film's official novelisation confirms that Willow performed a variety of "tricks" (i.e. not magic) before the piglet illusion.
But Willow had his own cheering-section, and they were so enthusiastic
that they even drew some curious spectators away from the tug-of-war.
Willow’s boyhood friend, Meegosh. stood solidly in his leather miner’s
apron, one arm around Ranon and the other around Mims. All three
wildly applauded every trick, even the old
pull-the-feathers-out-of-nowhere maneuver, which Willow actually did
quite well. Meegosh slapped his apron and yelled, “Bravo! Bravo!” so
lustily that he attracted the attention of Burglekutt. The Prefect
watched disdainfully from across the fairgrounds, pudgy hands spread
on his stomach.
Willow: Official Novelisation
As to how it was performed, it's typically done by having the arm simply be out of the way of the candle. The holes (in this case knotholes) are placed in such a way that they look like they're opposite, but in reality they're slightly offset, leaving enough space for the arm. You can see the illusion performed here
and here
add a comment |
Your Answer
StackExchange.ready(function()
var channelOptions =
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "186"
;
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
createEditor();
);
else
createEditor();
);
function createEditor()
StackExchange.prepareEditor(
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader:
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
,
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
);
);
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f216042%2fwas-willows-first-magic-display-blazing-arrow-through-arm-actual-magic-and-i%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
It appears to be based directly on this trick. Thus I assume it is meant to be sleight of hand like the piglet trick.
youtu.be/FyU26WN9kuY A do it yourself version of the trick that explains how it's done, at 4:10. Not sure if the manufactured ones work the same way.
– Kai
Jul 15 at 16:13
5
For the reference, "sleight" of hand is how you perform illusions. "Slight" of hand just means you've got really small hands.
– Valorum
Jul 15 at 16:13
1
@Valorum Or someone is disparaging your hands.
– Acccumulation
Jul 15 at 17:13
1
I prefer "legerdemain" or "prestidigitation," personally. "Skulduggery" is a bit underhanded, though.
– Draco18s
Jul 16 at 14:52
add a comment |
It appears to be based directly on this trick. Thus I assume it is meant to be sleight of hand like the piglet trick.
youtu.be/FyU26WN9kuY A do it yourself version of the trick that explains how it's done, at 4:10. Not sure if the manufactured ones work the same way.
– Kai
Jul 15 at 16:13
5
For the reference, "sleight" of hand is how you perform illusions. "Slight" of hand just means you've got really small hands.
– Valorum
Jul 15 at 16:13
1
@Valorum Or someone is disparaging your hands.
– Acccumulation
Jul 15 at 17:13
1
I prefer "legerdemain" or "prestidigitation," personally. "Skulduggery" is a bit underhanded, though.
– Draco18s
Jul 16 at 14:52
add a comment |
It appears to be based directly on this trick. Thus I assume it is meant to be sleight of hand like the piglet trick.
It appears to be based directly on this trick. Thus I assume it is meant to be sleight of hand like the piglet trick.
edited Jul 15 at 16:12
Valorum
434k122 gold badges3195 silver badges3368 bronze badges
434k122 gold badges3195 silver badges3368 bronze badges
answered Jul 15 at 15:00
NullWaltzNullWaltz
1115 bronze badges
1115 bronze badges
youtu.be/FyU26WN9kuY A do it yourself version of the trick that explains how it's done, at 4:10. Not sure if the manufactured ones work the same way.
– Kai
Jul 15 at 16:13
5
For the reference, "sleight" of hand is how you perform illusions. "Slight" of hand just means you've got really small hands.
– Valorum
Jul 15 at 16:13
1
@Valorum Or someone is disparaging your hands.
– Acccumulation
Jul 15 at 17:13
1
I prefer "legerdemain" or "prestidigitation," personally. "Skulduggery" is a bit underhanded, though.
– Draco18s
Jul 16 at 14:52
add a comment |
youtu.be/FyU26WN9kuY A do it yourself version of the trick that explains how it's done, at 4:10. Not sure if the manufactured ones work the same way.
– Kai
Jul 15 at 16:13
5
For the reference, "sleight" of hand is how you perform illusions. "Slight" of hand just means you've got really small hands.
– Valorum
Jul 15 at 16:13
1
@Valorum Or someone is disparaging your hands.
– Acccumulation
Jul 15 at 17:13
1
I prefer "legerdemain" or "prestidigitation," personally. "Skulduggery" is a bit underhanded, though.
– Draco18s
Jul 16 at 14:52
youtu.be/FyU26WN9kuY A do it yourself version of the trick that explains how it's done, at 4:10. Not sure if the manufactured ones work the same way.
– Kai
Jul 15 at 16:13
youtu.be/FyU26WN9kuY A do it yourself version of the trick that explains how it's done, at 4:10. Not sure if the manufactured ones work the same way.
– Kai
Jul 15 at 16:13
5
5
For the reference, "sleight" of hand is how you perform illusions. "Slight" of hand just means you've got really small hands.
– Valorum
Jul 15 at 16:13
For the reference, "sleight" of hand is how you perform illusions. "Slight" of hand just means you've got really small hands.
– Valorum
Jul 15 at 16:13
1
1
@Valorum Or someone is disparaging your hands.
– Acccumulation
Jul 15 at 17:13
@Valorum Or someone is disparaging your hands.
– Acccumulation
Jul 15 at 17:13
1
1
I prefer "legerdemain" or "prestidigitation," personally. "Skulduggery" is a bit underhanded, though.
– Draco18s
Jul 16 at 14:52
I prefer "legerdemain" or "prestidigitation," personally. "Skulduggery" is a bit underhanded, though.
– Draco18s
Jul 16 at 14:52
add a comment |
The film's official novelisation confirms that Willow performed a variety of "tricks" (i.e. not magic) before the piglet illusion.
But Willow had his own cheering-section, and they were so enthusiastic
that they even drew some curious spectators away from the tug-of-war.
Willow’s boyhood friend, Meegosh. stood solidly in his leather miner’s
apron, one arm around Ranon and the other around Mims. All three
wildly applauded every trick, even the old
pull-the-feathers-out-of-nowhere maneuver, which Willow actually did
quite well. Meegosh slapped his apron and yelled, “Bravo! Bravo!” so
lustily that he attracted the attention of Burglekutt. The Prefect
watched disdainfully from across the fairgrounds, pudgy hands spread
on his stomach.
Willow: Official Novelisation
As to how it was performed, it's typically done by having the arm simply be out of the way of the candle. The holes (in this case knotholes) are placed in such a way that they look like they're opposite, but in reality they're slightly offset, leaving enough space for the arm. You can see the illusion performed here
and here
add a comment |
The film's official novelisation confirms that Willow performed a variety of "tricks" (i.e. not magic) before the piglet illusion.
But Willow had his own cheering-section, and they were so enthusiastic
that they even drew some curious spectators away from the tug-of-war.
Willow’s boyhood friend, Meegosh. stood solidly in his leather miner’s
apron, one arm around Ranon and the other around Mims. All three
wildly applauded every trick, even the old
pull-the-feathers-out-of-nowhere maneuver, which Willow actually did
quite well. Meegosh slapped his apron and yelled, “Bravo! Bravo!” so
lustily that he attracted the attention of Burglekutt. The Prefect
watched disdainfully from across the fairgrounds, pudgy hands spread
on his stomach.
Willow: Official Novelisation
As to how it was performed, it's typically done by having the arm simply be out of the way of the candle. The holes (in this case knotholes) are placed in such a way that they look like they're opposite, but in reality they're slightly offset, leaving enough space for the arm. You can see the illusion performed here
and here
add a comment |
The film's official novelisation confirms that Willow performed a variety of "tricks" (i.e. not magic) before the piglet illusion.
But Willow had his own cheering-section, and they were so enthusiastic
that they even drew some curious spectators away from the tug-of-war.
Willow’s boyhood friend, Meegosh. stood solidly in his leather miner’s
apron, one arm around Ranon and the other around Mims. All three
wildly applauded every trick, even the old
pull-the-feathers-out-of-nowhere maneuver, which Willow actually did
quite well. Meegosh slapped his apron and yelled, “Bravo! Bravo!” so
lustily that he attracted the attention of Burglekutt. The Prefect
watched disdainfully from across the fairgrounds, pudgy hands spread
on his stomach.
Willow: Official Novelisation
As to how it was performed, it's typically done by having the arm simply be out of the way of the candle. The holes (in this case knotholes) are placed in such a way that they look like they're opposite, but in reality they're slightly offset, leaving enough space for the arm. You can see the illusion performed here
and here
The film's official novelisation confirms that Willow performed a variety of "tricks" (i.e. not magic) before the piglet illusion.
But Willow had his own cheering-section, and they were so enthusiastic
that they even drew some curious spectators away from the tug-of-war.
Willow’s boyhood friend, Meegosh. stood solidly in his leather miner’s
apron, one arm around Ranon and the other around Mims. All three
wildly applauded every trick, even the old
pull-the-feathers-out-of-nowhere maneuver, which Willow actually did
quite well. Meegosh slapped his apron and yelled, “Bravo! Bravo!” so
lustily that he attracted the attention of Burglekutt. The Prefect
watched disdainfully from across the fairgrounds, pudgy hands spread
on his stomach.
Willow: Official Novelisation
As to how it was performed, it's typically done by having the arm simply be out of the way of the candle. The holes (in this case knotholes) are placed in such a way that they look like they're opposite, but in reality they're slightly offset, leaving enough space for the arm. You can see the illusion performed here
and here
edited Jul 17 at 8:21
answered Jul 15 at 16:05
ValorumValorum
434k122 gold badges3195 silver badges3368 bronze badges
434k122 gold badges3195 silver badges3368 bronze badges
add a comment |
add a comment |
Thanks for contributing an answer to Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f216042%2fwas-willows-first-magic-display-blazing-arrow-through-arm-actual-magic-and-i%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
1
Given how large the cylinder is (it actually looks like a hollow log to me) compared to his arm, I'm sure it's just a matter of the arrow passing beside his arm. To keep from being burned, he could have put a cloth tube in there (that the arrow passes through) to insulate his skin. Or he could just have done it quickly; those flames are not that hot otherwise a "fire-eater" would get burned by incidental contact.
– DavidW
Jul 15 at 14:42
1
It's an illusion.
– Acccumulation
Jul 15 at 17:14