Bishop Berkeley's ideas put to the testScientist sets up experiment without pre-determining the outcomeShort story where the value of pi changes during the course of history, implying that the universe itself is changingID this story: aliens test Earthling children for psychic powersShort story where aliens test random earthling couple for procreationA short story about a scientist who invents a sanity test which most people failShort story: people rediscover how to do math and want to put people in bombsSpanish-language comic book story about time-traveling Jewish kids becoming the legendary Adam and Eve?Man training his aging father to pass a mandatory test to remain aliveShort story where both radiation and “demons” travel in straight lines so put bends in the entrywayShort story about a person using a barrow to put stones into the sea. Maybe by Le Guin?Main character wakes up from a suspended-animation “test” to discover that the world has fallen apartIdentify science-fiction short story where superintelligent test subjects fight with sense-based mental programming
Is Precocious Apprentice enough for Mystic Theurge?
Roman Numerals Equation 2
Would it be fair to use 1d30 (instead of rolling 2d20 and taking the higher die) for advantage rolls?
He is the first man to arrive here
Why is the A380’s with-reversers stopping distance the same as its no-reversers stopping distance?
Divisor Rich and Poor Numbers
When did Britain learn about American independence?
Why did the soldiers of the North disobey Jon?
How can I safely determine the output voltage and current of a transformer?
Why do galaxies collide?
Canadian citizen who is presently in litigation with a US-based company
Pedaling at different gear ratios on flat terrain: what's the point?
Non-African Click Languages
Why does Taylor’s series “work”?
Can I pay my credit card?
Given 0s on Assignments with suspected and dismissed cheating?
Is it standard to have the first week's pay indefinitely withheld?
Polynomial division: Is this trick obvious?
Why is so much ransomware breakable?
Solenoid fastest possible release - for how long should reversed polarity be applied?
What are the effects of eating many berries from the Goodberry spell per day?
Why are there five extra turns in tournament Magic?
How was the blinking terminal cursor invented?
Why would company (decision makers) wait for someone to retire, rather than lay them off, when their role is no longer needed?
Bishop Berkeley's ideas put to the test
Scientist sets up experiment without pre-determining the outcomeShort story where the value of pi changes during the course of history, implying that the universe itself is changingID this story: aliens test Earthling children for psychic powersShort story where aliens test random earthling couple for procreationA short story about a scientist who invents a sanity test which most people failShort story: people rediscover how to do math and want to put people in bombsSpanish-language comic book story about time-traveling Jewish kids becoming the legendary Adam and Eve?Man training his aging father to pass a mandatory test to remain aliveShort story where both radiation and “demons” travel in straight lines so put bends in the entrywayShort story about a person using a barrow to put stones into the sea. Maybe by Le Guin?Main character wakes up from a suspended-animation “test” to discover that the world has fallen apartIdentify science-fiction short story where superintelligent test subjects fight with sense-based mental programming
.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__bot-mid-leaderboard:empty margin-bottom:0;
Bishop Berkeley (who, however, is not credited in the story) is known today for his idea that material things only exist because we think about them, that mind is truly more important than matter. What if he were right? In that case, discoveries about the material world might just be creative inventions of the mind, not really discoveries at all. Our increasingly complex society and technology might be nothing more than an act of the imagination.
I no longer remember much about this story other than these bare bones, but the upshot is that the characters return to the simplest state of imagination. For a while, everyone and everything vanishes, and there is darkness without form. Then light dawns anew, and there is only one man, one woman, and a snake.
story-identification short-stories philosophy
add a comment |
Bishop Berkeley (who, however, is not credited in the story) is known today for his idea that material things only exist because we think about them, that mind is truly more important than matter. What if he were right? In that case, discoveries about the material world might just be creative inventions of the mind, not really discoveries at all. Our increasingly complex society and technology might be nothing more than an act of the imagination.
I no longer remember much about this story other than these bare bones, but the upshot is that the characters return to the simplest state of imagination. For a while, everyone and everything vanishes, and there is darkness without form. Then light dawns anew, and there is only one man, one woman, and a snake.
story-identification short-stories philosophy
1
Already asked and answered somewhere here
– Adamant
May 11 at 16:16
2
scifi.stackexchange.com/q/183773/51379
– Adamant
May 11 at 16:21
2
It's not the story you are looking for, but the short story Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius, by Borges, describes a world (sort of) in which Berkeley's idealism is regarded to be true.
– rafa11111
May 12 at 2:02
My Spanish-speaking friends continually refer to Borges. So far I've read only two of his stories, but I see that I will have to repair this lack, and soon.
– Invisible Trihedron
May 12 at 2:10
add a comment |
Bishop Berkeley (who, however, is not credited in the story) is known today for his idea that material things only exist because we think about them, that mind is truly more important than matter. What if he were right? In that case, discoveries about the material world might just be creative inventions of the mind, not really discoveries at all. Our increasingly complex society and technology might be nothing more than an act of the imagination.
I no longer remember much about this story other than these bare bones, but the upshot is that the characters return to the simplest state of imagination. For a while, everyone and everything vanishes, and there is darkness without form. Then light dawns anew, and there is only one man, one woman, and a snake.
story-identification short-stories philosophy
Bishop Berkeley (who, however, is not credited in the story) is known today for his idea that material things only exist because we think about them, that mind is truly more important than matter. What if he were right? In that case, discoveries about the material world might just be creative inventions of the mind, not really discoveries at all. Our increasingly complex society and technology might be nothing more than an act of the imagination.
I no longer remember much about this story other than these bare bones, but the upshot is that the characters return to the simplest state of imagination. For a while, everyone and everything vanishes, and there is darkness without form. Then light dawns anew, and there is only one man, one woman, and a snake.
story-identification short-stories philosophy
story-identification short-stories philosophy
edited May 12 at 1:48
Invisible Trihedron
asked May 11 at 14:27
Invisible TrihedronInvisible Trihedron
99214
99214
1
Already asked and answered somewhere here
– Adamant
May 11 at 16:16
2
scifi.stackexchange.com/q/183773/51379
– Adamant
May 11 at 16:21
2
It's not the story you are looking for, but the short story Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius, by Borges, describes a world (sort of) in which Berkeley's idealism is regarded to be true.
– rafa11111
May 12 at 2:02
My Spanish-speaking friends continually refer to Borges. So far I've read only two of his stories, but I see that I will have to repair this lack, and soon.
– Invisible Trihedron
May 12 at 2:10
add a comment |
1
Already asked and answered somewhere here
– Adamant
May 11 at 16:16
2
scifi.stackexchange.com/q/183773/51379
– Adamant
May 11 at 16:21
2
It's not the story you are looking for, but the short story Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius, by Borges, describes a world (sort of) in which Berkeley's idealism is regarded to be true.
– rafa11111
May 12 at 2:02
My Spanish-speaking friends continually refer to Borges. So far I've read only two of his stories, but I see that I will have to repair this lack, and soon.
– Invisible Trihedron
May 12 at 2:10
1
1
Already asked and answered somewhere here
– Adamant
May 11 at 16:16
Already asked and answered somewhere here
– Adamant
May 11 at 16:16
2
2
scifi.stackexchange.com/q/183773/51379
– Adamant
May 11 at 16:21
scifi.stackexchange.com/q/183773/51379
– Adamant
May 11 at 16:21
2
2
It's not the story you are looking for, but the short story Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius, by Borges, describes a world (sort of) in which Berkeley's idealism is regarded to be true.
– rafa11111
May 12 at 2:02
It's not the story you are looking for, but the short story Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius, by Borges, describes a world (sort of) in which Berkeley's idealism is regarded to be true.
– rafa11111
May 12 at 2:02
My Spanish-speaking friends continually refer to Borges. So far I've read only two of his stories, but I see that I will have to repair this lack, and soon.
– Invisible Trihedron
May 12 at 2:10
My Spanish-speaking friends continually refer to Borges. So far I've read only two of his stories, but I see that I will have to repair this lack, and soon.
– Invisible Trihedron
May 12 at 2:10
add a comment |
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
"The New Reality", a novelette by Charles L. Harness, also my (unaccepted) answer to this old question and this one; first published in Thrilling Wonder Stories, December 1950, available at the Internet Archive. The story matches your description, but Bishop Berkeley is not mentioned. Does any of these covers look familiar?
The theory:
The ontologist continued rapidly. "All of you doubt my sanity. A week ago I would have, too. But since then I've done a great deal of research in the history of science. and I repeat, the universe is the work of man. I believe that man began his existence in some incredibly simple world—the original and true noumenon of our present universe. And that over the centuries man expanded his little world into its present vastness and incomprehensible intricacy solely by dint of imagination.
"Consequently, I believe that what most of you call the 'real' world has been changing ever since our ancestors began to think."
The mad scientist's experiment:
"Your apparatus," said Prentiss, "is going to provide just such a photon. And I think it will be a highly confused little photon, just as your experimental rat was, that night not so long ago. I think it was Schroedinger who said that these physical particles were startlingly human in many of their aspects. Yes, your photon will be given a choice of equal probability. Shall he reflect? Shall he refract? The chances are 50 percent for either choice. He will have no reason for selecting one in preference to the other.
There will have been no swarm of preceding photons to set up a traffic guide
for him. He'll be puzzled; and trying to meet a situation for which he has no
proper response, he'll slow down. And when he does, he'll cease to be a photon, which must travel at the speed of light or cease to exist. Like your rat, like many human beings, he solves the unsolvable by disintegrating."
Luce said : "And when it disintegrates, there disappears one of the lambdas that hold together the Einstein space-time continuum. And when that
goes, what's left can be only final reality untainted by theory or imagination. Do you see any flaw in my plan?"
The end of the world:
The exploding bomb—the caving cottage walls—were hanging somewhere, frozen fast in an immutable, eternal stasis.
Luce had separated this fleeting unseen dimension from the creatures and things that had flowed along it. There is no existence without change along a temporal continuum. And now the continuum had been shattered.
Was this, then, the fate of all tangible things—of all humanity?
Were none of them—not even the two or three who understood advanced ontology—to get through?
There was nothing but a black, eerie silence all around.
The snake:
And what about Luce?
Had the demonic professor possessed sufficient mental elasticity to slip through?
He'd soon know.
The ontologist relaxed again, and began floating through a dreamy patch of light and darkness. A pale glow began gradually to form about his eyes, and shadowy things began to form, dissolve, and reform.
He felt a great rush of gratitude. At least the shape of final reality was to be visible.
And then, at about the spot where Luce had stood, he saw the Eyes—two tiny red flames, transfixing him with unimaginable fury.
An unholy aura was playing about the sinuous shadow that contained the jeweled flames. Those eyes were brilliant, horrid facets of hate in the head of a huge, coiling serpent-thing! Snake-Eyes!
The new Adam and Eve:
Meta-universe, by whatever name you called it, was beautiful, like a gorgeous garden. What a pity he must live and die here alone, with nothing but a lot of animals for company. He’d willingly give an arm, or at least a rib, if — "Adam Prentiss! Adam!"
He whirled and stared toward the orchard in elated disbelief.
"E! Eve!"
She'd got through!
The whole world, and just the two of them!
His heart was pounding ecstatically as he began to run lithely upwind.
And they'd keep it this way, simple and sweet, forever, and their children after them. To hell with science and progress! (Well, within practical limits, of course.)
As he ran, there rippled about his quivering nostrils the seductive scent of apple blossoms.
3
For what it's worth, this is the story that immediately popped into my head when reading the story-id request.
– user888379
May 11 at 20:09
5
This must be the best of all the stories where the characters turn out to be Adam and Eve.
– user14111
May 11 at 20:55
1
Thank you, Adamant and user14111! I will be glad to read this story again. I recall the cover of The Last Man on Earth, an anthology edited by Asimov et al. (1982). I corrected my introductory statement about Bishop Berkeley, who turns out not to be credited in the story. The idea, however, is generally ascribed to him in Western philosophy, and curious readers can read more about subjective idealism here: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subjective_idealism
– Invisible Trihedron
May 12 at 1:58
1
And what a wonderful word, "ontology": the study of being. "Paleontology" is, then, the study of ancient beings.
– Invisible Trihedron
May 12 at 2:01
add a comment |
Your Answer
StackExchange.ready(function()
var channelOptions =
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "186"
;
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
createEditor();
);
else
createEditor();
);
function createEditor()
StackExchange.prepareEditor(
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader:
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
,
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
);
);
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f212224%2fbishop-berkeleys-ideas-put-to-the-test%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
"The New Reality", a novelette by Charles L. Harness, also my (unaccepted) answer to this old question and this one; first published in Thrilling Wonder Stories, December 1950, available at the Internet Archive. The story matches your description, but Bishop Berkeley is not mentioned. Does any of these covers look familiar?
The theory:
The ontologist continued rapidly. "All of you doubt my sanity. A week ago I would have, too. But since then I've done a great deal of research in the history of science. and I repeat, the universe is the work of man. I believe that man began his existence in some incredibly simple world—the original and true noumenon of our present universe. And that over the centuries man expanded his little world into its present vastness and incomprehensible intricacy solely by dint of imagination.
"Consequently, I believe that what most of you call the 'real' world has been changing ever since our ancestors began to think."
The mad scientist's experiment:
"Your apparatus," said Prentiss, "is going to provide just such a photon. And I think it will be a highly confused little photon, just as your experimental rat was, that night not so long ago. I think it was Schroedinger who said that these physical particles were startlingly human in many of their aspects. Yes, your photon will be given a choice of equal probability. Shall he reflect? Shall he refract? The chances are 50 percent for either choice. He will have no reason for selecting one in preference to the other.
There will have been no swarm of preceding photons to set up a traffic guide
for him. He'll be puzzled; and trying to meet a situation for which he has no
proper response, he'll slow down. And when he does, he'll cease to be a photon, which must travel at the speed of light or cease to exist. Like your rat, like many human beings, he solves the unsolvable by disintegrating."
Luce said : "And when it disintegrates, there disappears one of the lambdas that hold together the Einstein space-time continuum. And when that
goes, what's left can be only final reality untainted by theory or imagination. Do you see any flaw in my plan?"
The end of the world:
The exploding bomb—the caving cottage walls—were hanging somewhere, frozen fast in an immutable, eternal stasis.
Luce had separated this fleeting unseen dimension from the creatures and things that had flowed along it. There is no existence without change along a temporal continuum. And now the continuum had been shattered.
Was this, then, the fate of all tangible things—of all humanity?
Were none of them—not even the two or three who understood advanced ontology—to get through?
There was nothing but a black, eerie silence all around.
The snake:
And what about Luce?
Had the demonic professor possessed sufficient mental elasticity to slip through?
He'd soon know.
The ontologist relaxed again, and began floating through a dreamy patch of light and darkness. A pale glow began gradually to form about his eyes, and shadowy things began to form, dissolve, and reform.
He felt a great rush of gratitude. At least the shape of final reality was to be visible.
And then, at about the spot where Luce had stood, he saw the Eyes—two tiny red flames, transfixing him with unimaginable fury.
An unholy aura was playing about the sinuous shadow that contained the jeweled flames. Those eyes were brilliant, horrid facets of hate in the head of a huge, coiling serpent-thing! Snake-Eyes!
The new Adam and Eve:
Meta-universe, by whatever name you called it, was beautiful, like a gorgeous garden. What a pity he must live and die here alone, with nothing but a lot of animals for company. He’d willingly give an arm, or at least a rib, if — "Adam Prentiss! Adam!"
He whirled and stared toward the orchard in elated disbelief.
"E! Eve!"
She'd got through!
The whole world, and just the two of them!
His heart was pounding ecstatically as he began to run lithely upwind.
And they'd keep it this way, simple and sweet, forever, and their children after them. To hell with science and progress! (Well, within practical limits, of course.)
As he ran, there rippled about his quivering nostrils the seductive scent of apple blossoms.
3
For what it's worth, this is the story that immediately popped into my head when reading the story-id request.
– user888379
May 11 at 20:09
5
This must be the best of all the stories where the characters turn out to be Adam and Eve.
– user14111
May 11 at 20:55
1
Thank you, Adamant and user14111! I will be glad to read this story again. I recall the cover of The Last Man on Earth, an anthology edited by Asimov et al. (1982). I corrected my introductory statement about Bishop Berkeley, who turns out not to be credited in the story. The idea, however, is generally ascribed to him in Western philosophy, and curious readers can read more about subjective idealism here: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subjective_idealism
– Invisible Trihedron
May 12 at 1:58
1
And what a wonderful word, "ontology": the study of being. "Paleontology" is, then, the study of ancient beings.
– Invisible Trihedron
May 12 at 2:01
add a comment |
"The New Reality", a novelette by Charles L. Harness, also my (unaccepted) answer to this old question and this one; first published in Thrilling Wonder Stories, December 1950, available at the Internet Archive. The story matches your description, but Bishop Berkeley is not mentioned. Does any of these covers look familiar?
The theory:
The ontologist continued rapidly. "All of you doubt my sanity. A week ago I would have, too. But since then I've done a great deal of research in the history of science. and I repeat, the universe is the work of man. I believe that man began his existence in some incredibly simple world—the original and true noumenon of our present universe. And that over the centuries man expanded his little world into its present vastness and incomprehensible intricacy solely by dint of imagination.
"Consequently, I believe that what most of you call the 'real' world has been changing ever since our ancestors began to think."
The mad scientist's experiment:
"Your apparatus," said Prentiss, "is going to provide just such a photon. And I think it will be a highly confused little photon, just as your experimental rat was, that night not so long ago. I think it was Schroedinger who said that these physical particles were startlingly human in many of their aspects. Yes, your photon will be given a choice of equal probability. Shall he reflect? Shall he refract? The chances are 50 percent for either choice. He will have no reason for selecting one in preference to the other.
There will have been no swarm of preceding photons to set up a traffic guide
for him. He'll be puzzled; and trying to meet a situation for which he has no
proper response, he'll slow down. And when he does, he'll cease to be a photon, which must travel at the speed of light or cease to exist. Like your rat, like many human beings, he solves the unsolvable by disintegrating."
Luce said : "And when it disintegrates, there disappears one of the lambdas that hold together the Einstein space-time continuum. And when that
goes, what's left can be only final reality untainted by theory or imagination. Do you see any flaw in my plan?"
The end of the world:
The exploding bomb—the caving cottage walls—were hanging somewhere, frozen fast in an immutable, eternal stasis.
Luce had separated this fleeting unseen dimension from the creatures and things that had flowed along it. There is no existence without change along a temporal continuum. And now the continuum had been shattered.
Was this, then, the fate of all tangible things—of all humanity?
Were none of them—not even the two or three who understood advanced ontology—to get through?
There was nothing but a black, eerie silence all around.
The snake:
And what about Luce?
Had the demonic professor possessed sufficient mental elasticity to slip through?
He'd soon know.
The ontologist relaxed again, and began floating through a dreamy patch of light and darkness. A pale glow began gradually to form about his eyes, and shadowy things began to form, dissolve, and reform.
He felt a great rush of gratitude. At least the shape of final reality was to be visible.
And then, at about the spot where Luce had stood, he saw the Eyes—two tiny red flames, transfixing him with unimaginable fury.
An unholy aura was playing about the sinuous shadow that contained the jeweled flames. Those eyes were brilliant, horrid facets of hate in the head of a huge, coiling serpent-thing! Snake-Eyes!
The new Adam and Eve:
Meta-universe, by whatever name you called it, was beautiful, like a gorgeous garden. What a pity he must live and die here alone, with nothing but a lot of animals for company. He’d willingly give an arm, or at least a rib, if — "Adam Prentiss! Adam!"
He whirled and stared toward the orchard in elated disbelief.
"E! Eve!"
She'd got through!
The whole world, and just the two of them!
His heart was pounding ecstatically as he began to run lithely upwind.
And they'd keep it this way, simple and sweet, forever, and their children after them. To hell with science and progress! (Well, within practical limits, of course.)
As he ran, there rippled about his quivering nostrils the seductive scent of apple blossoms.
3
For what it's worth, this is the story that immediately popped into my head when reading the story-id request.
– user888379
May 11 at 20:09
5
This must be the best of all the stories where the characters turn out to be Adam and Eve.
– user14111
May 11 at 20:55
1
Thank you, Adamant and user14111! I will be glad to read this story again. I recall the cover of The Last Man on Earth, an anthology edited by Asimov et al. (1982). I corrected my introductory statement about Bishop Berkeley, who turns out not to be credited in the story. The idea, however, is generally ascribed to him in Western philosophy, and curious readers can read more about subjective idealism here: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subjective_idealism
– Invisible Trihedron
May 12 at 1:58
1
And what a wonderful word, "ontology": the study of being. "Paleontology" is, then, the study of ancient beings.
– Invisible Trihedron
May 12 at 2:01
add a comment |
"The New Reality", a novelette by Charles L. Harness, also my (unaccepted) answer to this old question and this one; first published in Thrilling Wonder Stories, December 1950, available at the Internet Archive. The story matches your description, but Bishop Berkeley is not mentioned. Does any of these covers look familiar?
The theory:
The ontologist continued rapidly. "All of you doubt my sanity. A week ago I would have, too. But since then I've done a great deal of research in the history of science. and I repeat, the universe is the work of man. I believe that man began his existence in some incredibly simple world—the original and true noumenon of our present universe. And that over the centuries man expanded his little world into its present vastness and incomprehensible intricacy solely by dint of imagination.
"Consequently, I believe that what most of you call the 'real' world has been changing ever since our ancestors began to think."
The mad scientist's experiment:
"Your apparatus," said Prentiss, "is going to provide just such a photon. And I think it will be a highly confused little photon, just as your experimental rat was, that night not so long ago. I think it was Schroedinger who said that these physical particles were startlingly human in many of their aspects. Yes, your photon will be given a choice of equal probability. Shall he reflect? Shall he refract? The chances are 50 percent for either choice. He will have no reason for selecting one in preference to the other.
There will have been no swarm of preceding photons to set up a traffic guide
for him. He'll be puzzled; and trying to meet a situation for which he has no
proper response, he'll slow down. And when he does, he'll cease to be a photon, which must travel at the speed of light or cease to exist. Like your rat, like many human beings, he solves the unsolvable by disintegrating."
Luce said : "And when it disintegrates, there disappears one of the lambdas that hold together the Einstein space-time continuum. And when that
goes, what's left can be only final reality untainted by theory or imagination. Do you see any flaw in my plan?"
The end of the world:
The exploding bomb—the caving cottage walls—were hanging somewhere, frozen fast in an immutable, eternal stasis.
Luce had separated this fleeting unseen dimension from the creatures and things that had flowed along it. There is no existence without change along a temporal continuum. And now the continuum had been shattered.
Was this, then, the fate of all tangible things—of all humanity?
Were none of them—not even the two or three who understood advanced ontology—to get through?
There was nothing but a black, eerie silence all around.
The snake:
And what about Luce?
Had the demonic professor possessed sufficient mental elasticity to slip through?
He'd soon know.
The ontologist relaxed again, and began floating through a dreamy patch of light and darkness. A pale glow began gradually to form about his eyes, and shadowy things began to form, dissolve, and reform.
He felt a great rush of gratitude. At least the shape of final reality was to be visible.
And then, at about the spot where Luce had stood, he saw the Eyes—two tiny red flames, transfixing him with unimaginable fury.
An unholy aura was playing about the sinuous shadow that contained the jeweled flames. Those eyes were brilliant, horrid facets of hate in the head of a huge, coiling serpent-thing! Snake-Eyes!
The new Adam and Eve:
Meta-universe, by whatever name you called it, was beautiful, like a gorgeous garden. What a pity he must live and die here alone, with nothing but a lot of animals for company. He’d willingly give an arm, or at least a rib, if — "Adam Prentiss! Adam!"
He whirled and stared toward the orchard in elated disbelief.
"E! Eve!"
She'd got through!
The whole world, and just the two of them!
His heart was pounding ecstatically as he began to run lithely upwind.
And they'd keep it this way, simple and sweet, forever, and their children after them. To hell with science and progress! (Well, within practical limits, of course.)
As he ran, there rippled about his quivering nostrils the seductive scent of apple blossoms.
"The New Reality", a novelette by Charles L. Harness, also my (unaccepted) answer to this old question and this one; first published in Thrilling Wonder Stories, December 1950, available at the Internet Archive. The story matches your description, but Bishop Berkeley is not mentioned. Does any of these covers look familiar?
The theory:
The ontologist continued rapidly. "All of you doubt my sanity. A week ago I would have, too. But since then I've done a great deal of research in the history of science. and I repeat, the universe is the work of man. I believe that man began his existence in some incredibly simple world—the original and true noumenon of our present universe. And that over the centuries man expanded his little world into its present vastness and incomprehensible intricacy solely by dint of imagination.
"Consequently, I believe that what most of you call the 'real' world has been changing ever since our ancestors began to think."
The mad scientist's experiment:
"Your apparatus," said Prentiss, "is going to provide just such a photon. And I think it will be a highly confused little photon, just as your experimental rat was, that night not so long ago. I think it was Schroedinger who said that these physical particles were startlingly human in many of their aspects. Yes, your photon will be given a choice of equal probability. Shall he reflect? Shall he refract? The chances are 50 percent for either choice. He will have no reason for selecting one in preference to the other.
There will have been no swarm of preceding photons to set up a traffic guide
for him. He'll be puzzled; and trying to meet a situation for which he has no
proper response, he'll slow down. And when he does, he'll cease to be a photon, which must travel at the speed of light or cease to exist. Like your rat, like many human beings, he solves the unsolvable by disintegrating."
Luce said : "And when it disintegrates, there disappears one of the lambdas that hold together the Einstein space-time continuum. And when that
goes, what's left can be only final reality untainted by theory or imagination. Do you see any flaw in my plan?"
The end of the world:
The exploding bomb—the caving cottage walls—were hanging somewhere, frozen fast in an immutable, eternal stasis.
Luce had separated this fleeting unseen dimension from the creatures and things that had flowed along it. There is no existence without change along a temporal continuum. And now the continuum had been shattered.
Was this, then, the fate of all tangible things—of all humanity?
Were none of them—not even the two or three who understood advanced ontology—to get through?
There was nothing but a black, eerie silence all around.
The snake:
And what about Luce?
Had the demonic professor possessed sufficient mental elasticity to slip through?
He'd soon know.
The ontologist relaxed again, and began floating through a dreamy patch of light and darkness. A pale glow began gradually to form about his eyes, and shadowy things began to form, dissolve, and reform.
He felt a great rush of gratitude. At least the shape of final reality was to be visible.
And then, at about the spot where Luce had stood, he saw the Eyes—two tiny red flames, transfixing him with unimaginable fury.
An unholy aura was playing about the sinuous shadow that contained the jeweled flames. Those eyes were brilliant, horrid facets of hate in the head of a huge, coiling serpent-thing! Snake-Eyes!
The new Adam and Eve:
Meta-universe, by whatever name you called it, was beautiful, like a gorgeous garden. What a pity he must live and die here alone, with nothing but a lot of animals for company. He’d willingly give an arm, or at least a rib, if — "Adam Prentiss! Adam!"
He whirled and stared toward the orchard in elated disbelief.
"E! Eve!"
She'd got through!
The whole world, and just the two of them!
His heart was pounding ecstatically as he began to run lithely upwind.
And they'd keep it this way, simple and sweet, forever, and their children after them. To hell with science and progress! (Well, within practical limits, of course.)
As he ran, there rippled about his quivering nostrils the seductive scent of apple blossoms.
edited May 12 at 1:30
answered May 11 at 19:38
user14111user14111
108k6426544
108k6426544
3
For what it's worth, this is the story that immediately popped into my head when reading the story-id request.
– user888379
May 11 at 20:09
5
This must be the best of all the stories where the characters turn out to be Adam and Eve.
– user14111
May 11 at 20:55
1
Thank you, Adamant and user14111! I will be glad to read this story again. I recall the cover of The Last Man on Earth, an anthology edited by Asimov et al. (1982). I corrected my introductory statement about Bishop Berkeley, who turns out not to be credited in the story. The idea, however, is generally ascribed to him in Western philosophy, and curious readers can read more about subjective idealism here: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subjective_idealism
– Invisible Trihedron
May 12 at 1:58
1
And what a wonderful word, "ontology": the study of being. "Paleontology" is, then, the study of ancient beings.
– Invisible Trihedron
May 12 at 2:01
add a comment |
3
For what it's worth, this is the story that immediately popped into my head when reading the story-id request.
– user888379
May 11 at 20:09
5
This must be the best of all the stories where the characters turn out to be Adam and Eve.
– user14111
May 11 at 20:55
1
Thank you, Adamant and user14111! I will be glad to read this story again. I recall the cover of The Last Man on Earth, an anthology edited by Asimov et al. (1982). I corrected my introductory statement about Bishop Berkeley, who turns out not to be credited in the story. The idea, however, is generally ascribed to him in Western philosophy, and curious readers can read more about subjective idealism here: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subjective_idealism
– Invisible Trihedron
May 12 at 1:58
1
And what a wonderful word, "ontology": the study of being. "Paleontology" is, then, the study of ancient beings.
– Invisible Trihedron
May 12 at 2:01
3
3
For what it's worth, this is the story that immediately popped into my head when reading the story-id request.
– user888379
May 11 at 20:09
For what it's worth, this is the story that immediately popped into my head when reading the story-id request.
– user888379
May 11 at 20:09
5
5
This must be the best of all the stories where the characters turn out to be Adam and Eve.
– user14111
May 11 at 20:55
This must be the best of all the stories where the characters turn out to be Adam and Eve.
– user14111
May 11 at 20:55
1
1
Thank you, Adamant and user14111! I will be glad to read this story again. I recall the cover of The Last Man on Earth, an anthology edited by Asimov et al. (1982). I corrected my introductory statement about Bishop Berkeley, who turns out not to be credited in the story. The idea, however, is generally ascribed to him in Western philosophy, and curious readers can read more about subjective idealism here: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subjective_idealism
– Invisible Trihedron
May 12 at 1:58
Thank you, Adamant and user14111! I will be glad to read this story again. I recall the cover of The Last Man on Earth, an anthology edited by Asimov et al. (1982). I corrected my introductory statement about Bishop Berkeley, who turns out not to be credited in the story. The idea, however, is generally ascribed to him in Western philosophy, and curious readers can read more about subjective idealism here: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subjective_idealism
– Invisible Trihedron
May 12 at 1:58
1
1
And what a wonderful word, "ontology": the study of being. "Paleontology" is, then, the study of ancient beings.
– Invisible Trihedron
May 12 at 2:01
And what a wonderful word, "ontology": the study of being. "Paleontology" is, then, the study of ancient beings.
– Invisible Trihedron
May 12 at 2:01
add a comment |
Thanks for contributing an answer to Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f212224%2fbishop-berkeleys-ideas-put-to-the-test%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
1
Already asked and answered somewhere here
– Adamant
May 11 at 16:16
2
scifi.stackexchange.com/q/183773/51379
– Adamant
May 11 at 16:21
2
It's not the story you are looking for, but the short story Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius, by Borges, describes a world (sort of) in which Berkeley's idealism is regarded to be true.
– rafa11111
May 12 at 2:02
My Spanish-speaking friends continually refer to Borges. So far I've read only two of his stories, but I see that I will have to repair this lack, and soon.
– Invisible Trihedron
May 12 at 2:10