Why do Martians have to wear space helmets?
What are the bumps on the Vega rocket
Do you know your 'KVZ's?
What's the minimum number of sensors for a hobby GPS waypoint-following UAV?
Cops: The Hidden OEIS Substring
definition of "percentile"
Storming Area 51
Graduate student with abysmal English writing skills, how to help
Why does my String turn into Integers instead of letters after I add characters with +?
When casting Eldritch Blast with the Agonizing Blast eldritch invocation, what do I add to my damage roll?
What's the maximum time an interrupt service routine can take to execute on atmega328p?
Why are they 'nude photos'?
Is purchasing foreign currency before going abroad a losing proposition?
Why does the autopilot disengage even when it does not receive pilot input?
references on the empirical study on the practice of OR
What species of wasp is this? And how to get rid of them?
Professor falsely accusing me of cheating in a class he does not teach, two months after end of the class. What precautions should I take?
Did Lincoln tell Stowe "So you're the little woman that started this great war!"?
Novel where a group of scientists in a spaceship encounter various aliens
Single word for "refusing to move to next activity unless present one is completed."
Managing and organizing the massively increased number of classes after switching to SOLID?
Can fluent English speakers distinguish “steel”, “still” and “steal”?
Who has taken "my" Managed package namespace? Can we find out?
Are neural networks prone to catastrophic forgetting?
Is lack of functional requirements agile?
Why do Martians have to wear space helmets?
.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__bot-mid-leaderboard:empty margin-bottom:0;
In Mars Attacks!, it's established that Martians must wear those space helmets because, unlike us oxygen-breathing Earthlings, Martians must breathe nitrogen.
Is this a deliberate joke by the writers or just research failure? Because, of course, Earth's atmosphere is mainly nitrogen!
mars-attacks
|
show 10 more comments
In Mars Attacks!, it's established that Martians must wear those space helmets because, unlike us oxygen-breathing Earthlings, Martians must breathe nitrogen.
Is this a deliberate joke by the writers or just research failure? Because, of course, Earth's atmosphere is mainly nitrogen!
mars-attacks
28
Oxygen is a dangerous toxin; en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oxygen_toxicity
– Valorum
Jul 3 at 8:50
41
I do not know from the source, but the fact that they breathe nitrogen does not mean that other ingredients of air are not harmful to them. We breathe oxygen, but try breathing an air with a few % of CO2 or CO, even if oxygen is kept on the same level (21%) - you will die.
– Edmund Dantes
Jul 3 at 8:50
9
The massive release of oxygen in atmosphere en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Oxidation_Event lead to the exctinction of many anaerobic organisms
– nicolallias
Jul 3 at 8:56
18
I always assumed it was a joke. A. It seems like quite a coincidence to choose nitrogen out of all possible elements, B. Air being mostly nitrogen is fairly common knowledge, so it's unlikely they just missed it, and C. The movie is a comedy, and making jokes is its business. It being a joke seems like a safe assumption, no?
– Misha R
Jul 3 at 11:54
4
Interestingly enough, the actual Martian atmosphere is only about 2.6% nitrogen. It's mainly carbon dioxide. Makes the idea even stranger.
– jpmc26
Jul 4 at 0:47
|
show 10 more comments
In Mars Attacks!, it's established that Martians must wear those space helmets because, unlike us oxygen-breathing Earthlings, Martians must breathe nitrogen.
Is this a deliberate joke by the writers or just research failure? Because, of course, Earth's atmosphere is mainly nitrogen!
mars-attacks
In Mars Attacks!, it's established that Martians must wear those space helmets because, unlike us oxygen-breathing Earthlings, Martians must breathe nitrogen.
Is this a deliberate joke by the writers or just research failure? Because, of course, Earth's atmosphere is mainly nitrogen!
mars-attacks
mars-attacks
edited Jul 3 at 10:30
user14111
111k6 gold badges444 silver badges560 bronze badges
111k6 gold badges444 silver badges560 bronze badges
asked Jul 3 at 8:34
colmdecolmde
2,2812 gold badges19 silver badges28 bronze badges
2,2812 gold badges19 silver badges28 bronze badges
28
Oxygen is a dangerous toxin; en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oxygen_toxicity
– Valorum
Jul 3 at 8:50
41
I do not know from the source, but the fact that they breathe nitrogen does not mean that other ingredients of air are not harmful to them. We breathe oxygen, but try breathing an air with a few % of CO2 or CO, even if oxygen is kept on the same level (21%) - you will die.
– Edmund Dantes
Jul 3 at 8:50
9
The massive release of oxygen in atmosphere en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Oxidation_Event lead to the exctinction of many anaerobic organisms
– nicolallias
Jul 3 at 8:56
18
I always assumed it was a joke. A. It seems like quite a coincidence to choose nitrogen out of all possible elements, B. Air being mostly nitrogen is fairly common knowledge, so it's unlikely they just missed it, and C. The movie is a comedy, and making jokes is its business. It being a joke seems like a safe assumption, no?
– Misha R
Jul 3 at 11:54
4
Interestingly enough, the actual Martian atmosphere is only about 2.6% nitrogen. It's mainly carbon dioxide. Makes the idea even stranger.
– jpmc26
Jul 4 at 0:47
|
show 10 more comments
28
Oxygen is a dangerous toxin; en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oxygen_toxicity
– Valorum
Jul 3 at 8:50
41
I do not know from the source, but the fact that they breathe nitrogen does not mean that other ingredients of air are not harmful to them. We breathe oxygen, but try breathing an air with a few % of CO2 or CO, even if oxygen is kept on the same level (21%) - you will die.
– Edmund Dantes
Jul 3 at 8:50
9
The massive release of oxygen in atmosphere en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Oxidation_Event lead to the exctinction of many anaerobic organisms
– nicolallias
Jul 3 at 8:56
18
I always assumed it was a joke. A. It seems like quite a coincidence to choose nitrogen out of all possible elements, B. Air being mostly nitrogen is fairly common knowledge, so it's unlikely they just missed it, and C. The movie is a comedy, and making jokes is its business. It being a joke seems like a safe assumption, no?
– Misha R
Jul 3 at 11:54
4
Interestingly enough, the actual Martian atmosphere is only about 2.6% nitrogen. It's mainly carbon dioxide. Makes the idea even stranger.
– jpmc26
Jul 4 at 0:47
28
28
Oxygen is a dangerous toxin; en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oxygen_toxicity
– Valorum
Jul 3 at 8:50
Oxygen is a dangerous toxin; en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oxygen_toxicity
– Valorum
Jul 3 at 8:50
41
41
I do not know from the source, but the fact that they breathe nitrogen does not mean that other ingredients of air are not harmful to them. We breathe oxygen, but try breathing an air with a few % of CO2 or CO, even if oxygen is kept on the same level (21%) - you will die.
– Edmund Dantes
Jul 3 at 8:50
I do not know from the source, but the fact that they breathe nitrogen does not mean that other ingredients of air are not harmful to them. We breathe oxygen, but try breathing an air with a few % of CO2 or CO, even if oxygen is kept on the same level (21%) - you will die.
– Edmund Dantes
Jul 3 at 8:50
9
9
The massive release of oxygen in atmosphere en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Oxidation_Event lead to the exctinction of many anaerobic organisms
– nicolallias
Jul 3 at 8:56
The massive release of oxygen in atmosphere en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Oxidation_Event lead to the exctinction of many anaerobic organisms
– nicolallias
Jul 3 at 8:56
18
18
I always assumed it was a joke. A. It seems like quite a coincidence to choose nitrogen out of all possible elements, B. Air being mostly nitrogen is fairly common knowledge, so it's unlikely they just missed it, and C. The movie is a comedy, and making jokes is its business. It being a joke seems like a safe assumption, no?
– Misha R
Jul 3 at 11:54
I always assumed it was a joke. A. It seems like quite a coincidence to choose nitrogen out of all possible elements, B. Air being mostly nitrogen is fairly common knowledge, so it's unlikely they just missed it, and C. The movie is a comedy, and making jokes is its business. It being a joke seems like a safe assumption, no?
– Misha R
Jul 3 at 11:54
4
4
Interestingly enough, the actual Martian atmosphere is only about 2.6% nitrogen. It's mainly carbon dioxide. Makes the idea even stranger.
– jpmc26
Jul 4 at 0:47
Interestingly enough, the actual Martian atmosphere is only about 2.6% nitrogen. It's mainly carbon dioxide. Makes the idea even stranger.
– jpmc26
Jul 4 at 0:47
|
show 10 more comments
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
Mars Attacks! the film was based on Mars Attacks, a set of trading cards (aka bubblegum cards) published by Topps in 1962.

The martians in the film are depicted with helmets because that's how they're depicted on the trading cards. Any other explanation is going to be an after-the-fact rationalization.
You can see images of the entire set of cards here. There's a paragraph on the back of each one explaining what each one was. None of the text directly addresses why the martians wear helmets on earth.
Cards 48 and later depict Martians on Mars living in domed cities, which could indicate that the Martian atmosphere is no longer ideal for their needs. But Martians are also shown outside the cities without helmets, so they can apparently operate in the martian atmosphere to some extent.


Humans are shown as needing breathing gear on Mars (with flak helmets on the inside, naturally), except for card 52 which is inside a Martian city.

43
Flak helmets on the inside is ... awesome!
– davidbak
Jul 3 at 21:41
4
Fantastic answer. I had no idea that this was the origin of the Mars Attacks designs.
– s3raph86
Jul 4 at 5:03
2
I always interpreted the city domes to be like defensive walls rather than for gaseous control.
– Accio_Answer
Jul 4 at 7:37
6
Card 19 mentions that the Martians have oxygen lines on their suits.
– nick012000
Jul 4 at 8:58
2
My goodness... and people complain about gory MTG cards!
– T. Sar
Jul 5 at 13:26
|
show 1 more comment
We have confirmation from the film's official novelisation that these helmets are linked to a "life support backpack". It stands to reason that Earth's atmosphere, while containing nitrogen, isn't directly supportive of their form of life.
A dozen of Mars's finest marched in rows on either side of their
awesome Ambassador. These green creatures' long legs and arms were
ringed with jointed metal tubing. Their chests were crisscrossed with
flexible hoses that joined domed helmets to life-support backpacks.
The Martians carried toylike contraptions of tubes and spheres.
Based on the fact that the Martian infiltrator was able to survive by chewing a gum that was comprised of compressed nitrogen gas would suggest that the goal of the helmets is to provide an exclusively nitrogen (100%-ish) gas breathing environment and to exclude gases in Earth's atmosphere that would be poisonous to a Martian.
add a comment |
Mars atmosphere versus Earth atmosphere...
- Mars atmosphere is known to be much thinner than the oxygen/nitrogen rich Earth atmosphere, I think, containing mostly carbon dioxide, (anyone with more accurate knowledge feel free to correct me), so the inclusion of space helmets on the Martians in mars attacks is likely a reference to the fact that they are, well... hey, ... Martians.
- If we reference the SF megatext different planets represent inimical environments to invaders/non locals, think of the the Martians in HG Wells' War of the Worlds being undone by Earth bacteria.
- In the film itself, one Martian is shown chewing gum that gives off highly concentrated nitrogen (please correct me if I am wrong, it is a long time since I watched this...) indicating they breathe pure nitrogen and not an oxygen nitrogen mix and again emphasizing that the Martians are not from Earth.
- Rule of funny, the space helmets are deliberately ridiculous. This is not a film that cleaves close to actual science despite the fact that it was intended to feature a cameo by Carl Sagan. The bottom line is it's meant to be a comedy and is somewhat slapstick in its approach. Logic and scientific accuracy will always take second place to what seems funny.
Hey, you mean heads do not pop when listening to ridiculously high male voices? Well, maybe not literally, but...
– Philip Klöcking
Jul 3 at 13:53
#2 is (a spoiler) why they should have to.
– Mazura
Jul 5 at 16:09
add a comment |
Your Answer
StackExchange.ready(function()
var channelOptions =
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "186"
;
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
createEditor();
);
else
createEditor();
);
function createEditor()
StackExchange.prepareEditor(
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader:
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
,
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
);
);
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f215420%2fwhy-do-martians-have-to-wear-space-helmets%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
Mars Attacks! the film was based on Mars Attacks, a set of trading cards (aka bubblegum cards) published by Topps in 1962.

The martians in the film are depicted with helmets because that's how they're depicted on the trading cards. Any other explanation is going to be an after-the-fact rationalization.
You can see images of the entire set of cards here. There's a paragraph on the back of each one explaining what each one was. None of the text directly addresses why the martians wear helmets on earth.
Cards 48 and later depict Martians on Mars living in domed cities, which could indicate that the Martian atmosphere is no longer ideal for their needs. But Martians are also shown outside the cities without helmets, so they can apparently operate in the martian atmosphere to some extent.


Humans are shown as needing breathing gear on Mars (with flak helmets on the inside, naturally), except for card 52 which is inside a Martian city.

43
Flak helmets on the inside is ... awesome!
– davidbak
Jul 3 at 21:41
4
Fantastic answer. I had no idea that this was the origin of the Mars Attacks designs.
– s3raph86
Jul 4 at 5:03
2
I always interpreted the city domes to be like defensive walls rather than for gaseous control.
– Accio_Answer
Jul 4 at 7:37
6
Card 19 mentions that the Martians have oxygen lines on their suits.
– nick012000
Jul 4 at 8:58
2
My goodness... and people complain about gory MTG cards!
– T. Sar
Jul 5 at 13:26
|
show 1 more comment
Mars Attacks! the film was based on Mars Attacks, a set of trading cards (aka bubblegum cards) published by Topps in 1962.

The martians in the film are depicted with helmets because that's how they're depicted on the trading cards. Any other explanation is going to be an after-the-fact rationalization.
You can see images of the entire set of cards here. There's a paragraph on the back of each one explaining what each one was. None of the text directly addresses why the martians wear helmets on earth.
Cards 48 and later depict Martians on Mars living in domed cities, which could indicate that the Martian atmosphere is no longer ideal for their needs. But Martians are also shown outside the cities without helmets, so they can apparently operate in the martian atmosphere to some extent.


Humans are shown as needing breathing gear on Mars (with flak helmets on the inside, naturally), except for card 52 which is inside a Martian city.

43
Flak helmets on the inside is ... awesome!
– davidbak
Jul 3 at 21:41
4
Fantastic answer. I had no idea that this was the origin of the Mars Attacks designs.
– s3raph86
Jul 4 at 5:03
2
I always interpreted the city domes to be like defensive walls rather than for gaseous control.
– Accio_Answer
Jul 4 at 7:37
6
Card 19 mentions that the Martians have oxygen lines on their suits.
– nick012000
Jul 4 at 8:58
2
My goodness... and people complain about gory MTG cards!
– T. Sar
Jul 5 at 13:26
|
show 1 more comment
Mars Attacks! the film was based on Mars Attacks, a set of trading cards (aka bubblegum cards) published by Topps in 1962.

The martians in the film are depicted with helmets because that's how they're depicted on the trading cards. Any other explanation is going to be an after-the-fact rationalization.
You can see images of the entire set of cards here. There's a paragraph on the back of each one explaining what each one was. None of the text directly addresses why the martians wear helmets on earth.
Cards 48 and later depict Martians on Mars living in domed cities, which could indicate that the Martian atmosphere is no longer ideal for their needs. But Martians are also shown outside the cities without helmets, so they can apparently operate in the martian atmosphere to some extent.


Humans are shown as needing breathing gear on Mars (with flak helmets on the inside, naturally), except for card 52 which is inside a Martian city.

Mars Attacks! the film was based on Mars Attacks, a set of trading cards (aka bubblegum cards) published by Topps in 1962.

The martians in the film are depicted with helmets because that's how they're depicted on the trading cards. Any other explanation is going to be an after-the-fact rationalization.
You can see images of the entire set of cards here. There's a paragraph on the back of each one explaining what each one was. None of the text directly addresses why the martians wear helmets on earth.
Cards 48 and later depict Martians on Mars living in domed cities, which could indicate that the Martian atmosphere is no longer ideal for their needs. But Martians are also shown outside the cities without helmets, so they can apparently operate in the martian atmosphere to some extent.


Humans are shown as needing breathing gear on Mars (with flak helmets on the inside, naturally), except for card 52 which is inside a Martian city.

edited Jul 3 at 19:36
answered Jul 3 at 15:41
KensterKenster
4,3042 gold badges17 silver badges35 bronze badges
4,3042 gold badges17 silver badges35 bronze badges
43
Flak helmets on the inside is ... awesome!
– davidbak
Jul 3 at 21:41
4
Fantastic answer. I had no idea that this was the origin of the Mars Attacks designs.
– s3raph86
Jul 4 at 5:03
2
I always interpreted the city domes to be like defensive walls rather than for gaseous control.
– Accio_Answer
Jul 4 at 7:37
6
Card 19 mentions that the Martians have oxygen lines on their suits.
– nick012000
Jul 4 at 8:58
2
My goodness... and people complain about gory MTG cards!
– T. Sar
Jul 5 at 13:26
|
show 1 more comment
43
Flak helmets on the inside is ... awesome!
– davidbak
Jul 3 at 21:41
4
Fantastic answer. I had no idea that this was the origin of the Mars Attacks designs.
– s3raph86
Jul 4 at 5:03
2
I always interpreted the city domes to be like defensive walls rather than for gaseous control.
– Accio_Answer
Jul 4 at 7:37
6
Card 19 mentions that the Martians have oxygen lines on their suits.
– nick012000
Jul 4 at 8:58
2
My goodness... and people complain about gory MTG cards!
– T. Sar
Jul 5 at 13:26
43
43
Flak helmets on the inside is ... awesome!
– davidbak
Jul 3 at 21:41
Flak helmets on the inside is ... awesome!
– davidbak
Jul 3 at 21:41
4
4
Fantastic answer. I had no idea that this was the origin of the Mars Attacks designs.
– s3raph86
Jul 4 at 5:03
Fantastic answer. I had no idea that this was the origin of the Mars Attacks designs.
– s3raph86
Jul 4 at 5:03
2
2
I always interpreted the city domes to be like defensive walls rather than for gaseous control.
– Accio_Answer
Jul 4 at 7:37
I always interpreted the city domes to be like defensive walls rather than for gaseous control.
– Accio_Answer
Jul 4 at 7:37
6
6
Card 19 mentions that the Martians have oxygen lines on their suits.
– nick012000
Jul 4 at 8:58
Card 19 mentions that the Martians have oxygen lines on their suits.
– nick012000
Jul 4 at 8:58
2
2
My goodness... and people complain about gory MTG cards!
– T. Sar
Jul 5 at 13:26
My goodness... and people complain about gory MTG cards!
– T. Sar
Jul 5 at 13:26
|
show 1 more comment
We have confirmation from the film's official novelisation that these helmets are linked to a "life support backpack". It stands to reason that Earth's atmosphere, while containing nitrogen, isn't directly supportive of their form of life.
A dozen of Mars's finest marched in rows on either side of their
awesome Ambassador. These green creatures' long legs and arms were
ringed with jointed metal tubing. Their chests were crisscrossed with
flexible hoses that joined domed helmets to life-support backpacks.
The Martians carried toylike contraptions of tubes and spheres.
Based on the fact that the Martian infiltrator was able to survive by chewing a gum that was comprised of compressed nitrogen gas would suggest that the goal of the helmets is to provide an exclusively nitrogen (100%-ish) gas breathing environment and to exclude gases in Earth's atmosphere that would be poisonous to a Martian.
add a comment |
We have confirmation from the film's official novelisation that these helmets are linked to a "life support backpack". It stands to reason that Earth's atmosphere, while containing nitrogen, isn't directly supportive of their form of life.
A dozen of Mars's finest marched in rows on either side of their
awesome Ambassador. These green creatures' long legs and arms were
ringed with jointed metal tubing. Their chests were crisscrossed with
flexible hoses that joined domed helmets to life-support backpacks.
The Martians carried toylike contraptions of tubes and spheres.
Based on the fact that the Martian infiltrator was able to survive by chewing a gum that was comprised of compressed nitrogen gas would suggest that the goal of the helmets is to provide an exclusively nitrogen (100%-ish) gas breathing environment and to exclude gases in Earth's atmosphere that would be poisonous to a Martian.
add a comment |
We have confirmation from the film's official novelisation that these helmets are linked to a "life support backpack". It stands to reason that Earth's atmosphere, while containing nitrogen, isn't directly supportive of their form of life.
A dozen of Mars's finest marched in rows on either side of their
awesome Ambassador. These green creatures' long legs and arms were
ringed with jointed metal tubing. Their chests were crisscrossed with
flexible hoses that joined domed helmets to life-support backpacks.
The Martians carried toylike contraptions of tubes and spheres.
Based on the fact that the Martian infiltrator was able to survive by chewing a gum that was comprised of compressed nitrogen gas would suggest that the goal of the helmets is to provide an exclusively nitrogen (100%-ish) gas breathing environment and to exclude gases in Earth's atmosphere that would be poisonous to a Martian.
We have confirmation from the film's official novelisation that these helmets are linked to a "life support backpack". It stands to reason that Earth's atmosphere, while containing nitrogen, isn't directly supportive of their form of life.
A dozen of Mars's finest marched in rows on either side of their
awesome Ambassador. These green creatures' long legs and arms were
ringed with jointed metal tubing. Their chests were crisscrossed with
flexible hoses that joined domed helmets to life-support backpacks.
The Martians carried toylike contraptions of tubes and spheres.
Based on the fact that the Martian infiltrator was able to survive by chewing a gum that was comprised of compressed nitrogen gas would suggest that the goal of the helmets is to provide an exclusively nitrogen (100%-ish) gas breathing environment and to exclude gases in Earth's atmosphere that would be poisonous to a Martian.
answered Jul 3 at 21:34
ValorumValorum
431k122 gold badges3184 silver badges3358 bronze badges
431k122 gold badges3184 silver badges3358 bronze badges
add a comment |
add a comment |
Mars atmosphere versus Earth atmosphere...
- Mars atmosphere is known to be much thinner than the oxygen/nitrogen rich Earth atmosphere, I think, containing mostly carbon dioxide, (anyone with more accurate knowledge feel free to correct me), so the inclusion of space helmets on the Martians in mars attacks is likely a reference to the fact that they are, well... hey, ... Martians.
- If we reference the SF megatext different planets represent inimical environments to invaders/non locals, think of the the Martians in HG Wells' War of the Worlds being undone by Earth bacteria.
- In the film itself, one Martian is shown chewing gum that gives off highly concentrated nitrogen (please correct me if I am wrong, it is a long time since I watched this...) indicating they breathe pure nitrogen and not an oxygen nitrogen mix and again emphasizing that the Martians are not from Earth.
- Rule of funny, the space helmets are deliberately ridiculous. This is not a film that cleaves close to actual science despite the fact that it was intended to feature a cameo by Carl Sagan. The bottom line is it's meant to be a comedy and is somewhat slapstick in its approach. Logic and scientific accuracy will always take second place to what seems funny.
Hey, you mean heads do not pop when listening to ridiculously high male voices? Well, maybe not literally, but...
– Philip Klöcking
Jul 3 at 13:53
#2 is (a spoiler) why they should have to.
– Mazura
Jul 5 at 16:09
add a comment |
Mars atmosphere versus Earth atmosphere...
- Mars atmosphere is known to be much thinner than the oxygen/nitrogen rich Earth atmosphere, I think, containing mostly carbon dioxide, (anyone with more accurate knowledge feel free to correct me), so the inclusion of space helmets on the Martians in mars attacks is likely a reference to the fact that they are, well... hey, ... Martians.
- If we reference the SF megatext different planets represent inimical environments to invaders/non locals, think of the the Martians in HG Wells' War of the Worlds being undone by Earth bacteria.
- In the film itself, one Martian is shown chewing gum that gives off highly concentrated nitrogen (please correct me if I am wrong, it is a long time since I watched this...) indicating they breathe pure nitrogen and not an oxygen nitrogen mix and again emphasizing that the Martians are not from Earth.
- Rule of funny, the space helmets are deliberately ridiculous. This is not a film that cleaves close to actual science despite the fact that it was intended to feature a cameo by Carl Sagan. The bottom line is it's meant to be a comedy and is somewhat slapstick in its approach. Logic and scientific accuracy will always take second place to what seems funny.
Hey, you mean heads do not pop when listening to ridiculously high male voices? Well, maybe not literally, but...
– Philip Klöcking
Jul 3 at 13:53
#2 is (a spoiler) why they should have to.
– Mazura
Jul 5 at 16:09
add a comment |
Mars atmosphere versus Earth atmosphere...
- Mars atmosphere is known to be much thinner than the oxygen/nitrogen rich Earth atmosphere, I think, containing mostly carbon dioxide, (anyone with more accurate knowledge feel free to correct me), so the inclusion of space helmets on the Martians in mars attacks is likely a reference to the fact that they are, well... hey, ... Martians.
- If we reference the SF megatext different planets represent inimical environments to invaders/non locals, think of the the Martians in HG Wells' War of the Worlds being undone by Earth bacteria.
- In the film itself, one Martian is shown chewing gum that gives off highly concentrated nitrogen (please correct me if I am wrong, it is a long time since I watched this...) indicating they breathe pure nitrogen and not an oxygen nitrogen mix and again emphasizing that the Martians are not from Earth.
- Rule of funny, the space helmets are deliberately ridiculous. This is not a film that cleaves close to actual science despite the fact that it was intended to feature a cameo by Carl Sagan. The bottom line is it's meant to be a comedy and is somewhat slapstick in its approach. Logic and scientific accuracy will always take second place to what seems funny.
Mars atmosphere versus Earth atmosphere...
- Mars atmosphere is known to be much thinner than the oxygen/nitrogen rich Earth atmosphere, I think, containing mostly carbon dioxide, (anyone with more accurate knowledge feel free to correct me), so the inclusion of space helmets on the Martians in mars attacks is likely a reference to the fact that they are, well... hey, ... Martians.
- If we reference the SF megatext different planets represent inimical environments to invaders/non locals, think of the the Martians in HG Wells' War of the Worlds being undone by Earth bacteria.
- In the film itself, one Martian is shown chewing gum that gives off highly concentrated nitrogen (please correct me if I am wrong, it is a long time since I watched this...) indicating they breathe pure nitrogen and not an oxygen nitrogen mix and again emphasizing that the Martians are not from Earth.
- Rule of funny, the space helmets are deliberately ridiculous. This is not a film that cleaves close to actual science despite the fact that it was intended to feature a cameo by Carl Sagan. The bottom line is it's meant to be a comedy and is somewhat slapstick in its approach. Logic and scientific accuracy will always take second place to what seems funny.
edited Jul 3 at 13:22
TheLethalCarrot
67.6k29 gold badges439 silver badges481 bronze badges
67.6k29 gold badges439 silver badges481 bronze badges
answered Jul 3 at 13:18
dominic fondedominic fonde
2,7458 silver badges28 bronze badges
2,7458 silver badges28 bronze badges
Hey, you mean heads do not pop when listening to ridiculously high male voices? Well, maybe not literally, but...
– Philip Klöcking
Jul 3 at 13:53
#2 is (a spoiler) why they should have to.
– Mazura
Jul 5 at 16:09
add a comment |
Hey, you mean heads do not pop when listening to ridiculously high male voices? Well, maybe not literally, but...
– Philip Klöcking
Jul 3 at 13:53
#2 is (a spoiler) why they should have to.
– Mazura
Jul 5 at 16:09
Hey, you mean heads do not pop when listening to ridiculously high male voices? Well, maybe not literally, but...
– Philip Klöcking
Jul 3 at 13:53
Hey, you mean heads do not pop when listening to ridiculously high male voices? Well, maybe not literally, but...
– Philip Klöcking
Jul 3 at 13:53
#2 is (a spoiler) why they should have to.
– Mazura
Jul 5 at 16:09
#2 is (a spoiler) why they should have to.
– Mazura
Jul 5 at 16:09
add a comment |
Thanks for contributing an answer to Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f215420%2fwhy-do-martians-have-to-wear-space-helmets%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
28
Oxygen is a dangerous toxin; en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oxygen_toxicity
– Valorum
Jul 3 at 8:50
41
I do not know from the source, but the fact that they breathe nitrogen does not mean that other ingredients of air are not harmful to them. We breathe oxygen, but try breathing an air with a few % of CO2 or CO, even if oxygen is kept on the same level (21%) - you will die.
– Edmund Dantes
Jul 3 at 8:50
9
The massive release of oxygen in atmosphere en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Oxidation_Event lead to the exctinction of many anaerobic organisms
– nicolallias
Jul 3 at 8:56
18
I always assumed it was a joke. A. It seems like quite a coincidence to choose nitrogen out of all possible elements, B. Air being mostly nitrogen is fairly common knowledge, so it's unlikely they just missed it, and C. The movie is a comedy, and making jokes is its business. It being a joke seems like a safe assumption, no?
– Misha R
Jul 3 at 11:54
4
Interestingly enough, the actual Martian atmosphere is only about 2.6% nitrogen. It's mainly carbon dioxide. Makes the idea even stranger.
– jpmc26
Jul 4 at 0:47